# The After Age: Why We Are Going to Be OK and How You Can Help Us to Be Great By Ben Upham Source: https://theafterage.com/ # Part: We Are Going to Be OK ## Introduction The purpose of this book is to change the way you think about the world. At its heart, this change is about a shift in perspective. In the pages that follow, I will ask you to consider familiar topics from a different point of view, one that may be very different from the one you have now. You should expect to disagree, at least at first, with a lot of what you read here. That means, to get the most out of this book, you will need to be flexible and adventurous in your thinking. You will need to keep an open mind. For example, consider the following claim: There is no finer proof of the title of this book – that we are going to be OK and could be great – than the Covid-19 global pandemic. That may seem like a ridiculous thing to say, not to mention a little tone-deaf. Covid-19 is a disaster of epic proportions, one we will not soon forget. However, Covid is also strong evidence that we are all better off than we might assume. It is that apparent contradiction that makes it great practice in changing your perspective, not to mention the perfect introduction to this book. Disasters happen in every age. But Covid, like others, highlights how much our standards have risen and our capabilities have improved since the last time around. Far from showing us only how bad things are, the pandemic shows us – if we are willing to look – how much we have achieved. It is, in other words, evidence of human progress. When it comes to the Covid-19 pandemic, you have to look for the good news within the bad. But once you do, there’s plenty to find. For example, over two-thirds of deaths from Covid are people over 70. Yet only until very recently did the average human being live to 70. In other words, the majority of the effort made (successful and unsuccessful) to save lives was to save those of people who, at any other time in human history, statistically speaking would already be dead. It is not that it is wrong to do so! But our ancestors never had the luxury to care. We do. Clearly, our standards have risen, a lot. Our capabilities have risen alongside our standards. We rightly fear Mother Nature and her army of hidden pathogens like Covid-19. But once open war started and we Homo sapiens mobilized with our tools and our knowledge, it’s clear the coronavirus never stood a chance. As the disease spread, information about it, its cause, symptoms, and treatments spread faster, distributed by a globe-spanning human network as sophisticated as any natural system. Racing ahead of the pandemic, this system inspired new technologies and spurred action on a thousand different levels. Think of it this way: It took millions of years for this coronavirus to evolve into the contagious killer it is today. We developed a vaccine to knock it out in a few months. In other ways, like how we destroy the environment or drive species to extinction, this mismatch between our technical powers and nature’s defenses is depressing. But in this case, it’s pretty great. Go us! There is plenty more. Because of the pandemic, people were trapped in their homes, but we now have technology – only recently invented – that allows many to continue to work or have face-to-face conversations with family and friends without leaving the house. Hundreds of millions lost their jobs, but we now have governments that are willing and able to foot the bill for income lost in disasters. Our economies went into lockdown, and yet our food supply, electricity, water, and other essentials were barely affected. And so on. None of these things were true in the last pandemic, or if they were, only in a much, much more limited way. (And of course, much of it is still not true for many of us; more on that in a moment. But in the past, it wasn’t true for anyone.) Before I get carried away with how great all this progress is, allow me to repeat myself: I am not saying a pandemic is a good thing. Individual pain and suffering goes on every day, everywhere. A disaster like a pandemic heaps on more. But we shouldn’t make the mistake of taking individual examples of hardship and projecting them on to the world as a whole. If all you can see is that people are suffering then, well, good. That makes you human. It is right to see pain and suffering and not be blind to it. But don’t let it stop you from taking some perspective, too. We need both. For anyone who is pessimistic about the fate of the world, whether because of pandemics, or climate change, or nuclear war, or politics, or what have you, the Covid-19 pandemic is a wonderful opportunity for a little perspective, if you choose to take it. It is a reminder that we can survive the big stuff. That a body blow is not a death knell. Why does all this matter? It matters because, as I put it in the title, we could be great. But whether we will be hinges on accepting and understanding the first part of the title: We are going to be OK. Far from living on the edge of disaster, humanity – you, me, and everyone we know – are at the border of a world far better than the best of what we have now. But to be able to seize that opportunity first requires acknowledging it exists. Instead, there is a pervasive pessimism in my country and elsewhere about the future. Perhaps living through this crisis, and seeing that it has not led to the end of the world, will convince some people to take a more optimistic and empowered view of our collective future. For everyone else, I invite you to read on. The first goal of this book is to show you that the present and the future are a lot brighter than you might think. In the pages that follow, I define what I mean by the After Age and how it explains my optimism about the world today. I’ll show you why it is perfectly reasonable to believe we are going to be OK, mostly because we already are. If objections are rising in your mind, I ask you to suspend your disbelief a bit longer. I am not arguing things are perfect. Definitely not. I am certainly not arguing that the good times are equally distributed. Not even close. If you look at the evidence however, it’s hard not to see a strong trend in the right direction, for everyone. By considering an optimistic view of the future, you will feel better about the present, despite its many flaws. Existential anxiety about the future of the world is a source of real psychic unease. This unease is probably more influential than we realize, because it exists at a bedrock level in our minds, affecting everything else on top of it. In other words, if we are fundamentally unsure whether “everything is right with the world”, then any other happiness we have can seem more fragile, fleeting, and unsure. The fact that such existential anxiety is not backed up by the facts makes it even more tragic. It isn’t helping anyone, yourself included. But showing you we are going to be OK is just the start. My real goal is to convince you we could be great, and that you can help us get there. How to do so is what the rest of this book is about. If the coronavirus shows how far we have come, it also points out some of our continuing flaws. While they take many different forms, they share a common source: We are not good enough at cooperating with each other, as individuals and as groups of people of all sizes. Yet at the same time, the fruits of our progress are pushing us towards even greater cooperation, whether we want to or not. In our economies, our environment, our politics, and our cultural and social lives, simply maintaining a minimal degree of stability requires greater and greater cooperation, as I will explain. This clash, between our (totally understandable) reluctance to cooperate more, on the one hand, and the forces we have unleashed demanding greater cooperation, on the other, is causing conflict within and between nations, peoples, and individuals. This conflict is likely to get worse before it gets better. Brace yourselves. But we can be great! And I believe we will be. So hold on tight, and keep your eyes on the future. You have a part to play in it. The second part of this book is filled with actionable ideas for reconsidering the way you think about the world around you based on the goal of increasing cooperation between all of us. These ideas are grouped based on widening circles of concern, starting with the self and expanding all the way out to the national level, and beyond. But whatever the topic, they are focused on you, the individual, how you can change your perspective on the world around you, for both your benefit, and everyone’s. This book is designed to give you hope for the present, and new ideas to help you flourish in the future. But that is not why I wrote it. I wrote it because I want your help to keep the After Age going so its benefits can reach everyone alive. I see a bright future for us, but I know it is not guaranteed. I believe that changing how we perceive the world around us, and our place in it, even just slightly, is the best thing each of us can do to help all of us have a future that is great. Before we get there, however, I need to convince you we are going to be OK. That is the next chapter. ## The After Age > *A line drawn in history might as well be written in water. Yet at some point, a creek becomes a stream, a stream becomes a river, and a river becomes an ocean. Somewhere, we mark the passage of one age to the next. * Today we live in the After Age. Not all of us, not all of the time. But more and more of us, more and more of the time. If you are reading this, chances are you live in the After Age. What is the After Age? As the name suggests, it is after something. But what? The Cold War? The Industrial Revolution? The discovery of fire? The After Age is the age of human history after the biggest challenges to *individual* human life have been overcome. These are the challenges that defined our daily existence for as long as there have been humans, right up until around two to three hundred years ago, when, one by one, they began to retreat in the face of our intelligence, hard work, and cooperation. These challenges include obtaining sufficient food, clothing, and shelter; preventing disease, accidents, and poor health; defending against violence and war; and freeing ourselves from social, cultural, and political oppression.[^1] I know what you’re thinking: We aren’t “after” any of these things. Read the news, or just step out your front door, and you could probably spot several examples to the contrary. The same is likely true for your own life as well. Even if you live in the wealthiest country in the world, it’s likely some version of these troubles – lack of food, lack of security, lack of good health, lack of justice – have some effect on your life. The After Age is not a sudden, complete change in human life. It is a gradual transition that has been taking place for hundreds of years. Although the After Age started around 1750, or even earlier, it took at least 150 years to pick up steam around the world. Today it is still at various stages in different places. Nowhere is it “complete”. For this reason, the central idea of the After Age, that we as a species have solved the primary challenges to individual life, is still not true everywhere or for everyone, and is not completely true for anyone. The After Age is not just an era in time, or a geographic place, but a certain standard of living whose boundary, while expanding, is still blurry, uneven, and in flux from year to year, place to place, and even person to person. This slowly emerging reality is nonetheless visible virtually everywhere on Earth. If we don’t notice it, it is only because we have taken it for granted. But we shouldn’t take it for granted. We should remember and celebrate this new world every day because it shows not only how far we have come, but how far we could go in the future. Here are a few examples of what I am talking about: ***Today is after the time when hunger and the daily struggle for survival dominated human existence.*** Until very recently, getting enough food to survive – and avoiding death while doing so – defined the majority of our days on Earth for all but a small, privileged few. Today, for a growing majority of humanity, anxiety about whether they will have enough to eat is not an immediate concern, if it is there at all. This is certainly not true for every human being, unfortunately. But when we look back on all of human history before today, the fact that it is true for as many of us as it is is a miracle and an important milestone. ***Today is after the 40-year limit on life expectancy, unchanged for thousands of years, lifted.*** Starting in the 19th century, average life expectancy began to climb upwards and is now around 72 years, worldwide. It may eventually climb past 100, or more. While the increase is largely due to lower infant mortality (itself a great thing) it is also due to improvements in health care later in life and a generally higher standard of living. ***Today is after the threat of violence and warfare have receded from human life. ***This may seem an absurd claim for anyone who follows the news of mayhem occurring around the world. But what makes the headlines has a way of obscuring larger trends in per-capita violence, which have been trending downwards. These trends cover not just war, but violence between individuals, such as domestic abuse or murder. For most of human history, the possibility of violent assault or death, while uncommon, was several times more likely than it is now, perhaps hundreds of times more likely. For a small percentage of humanity trapped in one of the remaining war zones on this planet, violent death may be a constant threat, but it is no longer for the vast majority of us. This is a long-term trend, with many ups and downs. One nuclear war would make this a moot point – but a nuclear war would make everything a moot point. ***Today is after nearly every aspect of the natural world has been explored, the last “undiscovered territory” discovered, literally and figuratively.*** In the last 200 years, humanity has unlocked the secrets of everything from natural selection to quantum physics, from spaceflight to public sanitation. No category of knowledge has not been at least identified, and few have not been mapped extensively. True, there is still plenty more to learn. But where once science was a hidden world, today it is laid out before us like a feast. This knowledge has unlocked amazing powers that allow us to live far more pleasant and empowered lives than our ancestors. ***Today is after the establishment of the rule of law, not men, as the source of political power in most lives. ***From one democracy in the late 18th century (the United States of America), the world now boasts 118, 60% of all nations. Much has been made of a recent downward trend in the number and quality of democracies, but step back even just a little and that negative trend looks mild in the context of the enormous spread of democracy, and more importantly, the rule of law. The focus on whether certain nations are or are not “democratic” ignores the fact that even non-democracies are behaving better towards their people. Torture, imprisonment and execution without trial, arbitrary justice and governmental coercion have all become less common everywhere. Today, even non-democracies recognize the rule of law as the best way to establish a stable and prosperous order, even if they cannot or will not practice it all the time. The last 100 years or so have seen a steady spread of these improvements from their start in northern Europe to every corner of the world. Poverty persists, but fewer people live in absolute poverty every day, however it is defined. Living standards and life expectancy are up, violence and disease are down. The trends are unmistakable. To refuse to acknowledge them would be just as short-sighted as it would be if things were headed in the opposite direction. I am not saying that hunger, poor health, war, oppression or any other plague of humankind no longer exists. Nor am I saying they will ever disappear completely. But the retreat of these demons over the last 200 years or so was and is so dramatic, so unmistakable, that it marks a turning point in human history and the beginning of something new. Whether we call this new era “the After Age”, or something else (or don’t give it a name at all), it’s here. We must recognize that fact, how it affects us, and what, if anything, it means for how we live now and ought to on into the future. When I state, as I do in the title of this book, that “we are going to be OK” it is because of the facts I have just laid before you, and many, many more like them. They are evidence that human life *can* improve, because it *has* improved. And not just a little. A lot. This progress has soldiered on through economic upheavals, wars, revolutions (and pandemics!) – the entire rollercoaster of the last 200-300 years of history. We are going to be OK because, by any reasonable comparison to the past, *we already are OK*, and with each passing year more and more of us are even more OK. Remember, “OK” is a relative term. One person’s OK is another person’s miserable, and a third person’s great. But when the conditions in which we live are steadily improving, on average, over time – which is objectively true – then it stands to reason that, whatever the standard of OKness, it must be being achieved by more and more of us every day. Of course, our standards go up, too. What was once a miracle, like air travel or a vaccine for polio, becomes everyday and is taken for granted. I chose the word OK to describe the baseline standard of living in the After Age because it reflects the reality of our dissatisfaction with life, however good it is. OK is not bad, but it’s not great, either. Life may be merely OK because of some real hardship, or it may be merely OK because it is the human condition to constantly want what we do not have. Probably both. But while OK is not great, it is also not bad, and it is certainly not bad and getting worse. And yet that is exactly what so many believe. They believe, or just assume, we are headed towards disaster, or we are already there. They may come to this conclusion for scientific, political, or religious reasons. Or because of a specific fear: of global warming, immigration, terrorism, capitalism, socialism, religious extremism, secular immorality, nuclear war, ethnic strife, political corruption, artificial intelligence, asteroids, or a million others. Their fear may be of something that just happened yesterday, or might happen a hundred years from now. You may be one of these people. I will admit to occasionally feeling that way myself. That is why stepping back and getting some perspective is so important. Yes, there are serious flaws with the way the world works today. Injustice, stupidity, greed, violence, and cruelty run rampant, ruining lives and creating human-made tragedies on a daily basis. Natural disasters of all kinds create their own tragedies on top of the ones we inflict on ourselves. And yes, we do have the power to extinguish all life on Earth, at least theoretically. And no, not everyone enjoys the same level of security, freedom and prosperity that I do. Not even close. (Which is the number one reason I wrote this book.) But if these eternal flaws in human nature were truly as damning as we fear, nothing good would have ever been accomplished. Yet instead, human life has – on average – steadily improved. There is, in other words, a disconnect between what we fear is happening, and what is really happening. The disconnect is understandable. We are all absorbed in our own lives and our own problems, both petty and profound, and usually it’s hard for us to see the difference between the two. Big historical trends, even if they absolutely have an impact on the quality of our lives, are just so much background noise. Furthermore, when a threat or crisis does appear, like climate change, Covid-19, or some political controversy, our awareness of the world shrinks to focus on it at the expense of everything else. We become incapable of seeing past this frightening thing looming ahead of us. We forget that human civilization has endured much worse and yet continued its relentless rise upwards. I am not denying disasters. Certainly, disasters happen. But disasters are not the same as Armageddon. Some people argue that we were happier in the past, or less stressed, or less lonely, or some other quality that is very difficult to measure accurately. The fact that it is so hard to measure these things makes them very convenient arguments for those whose ideologies or temperament rely on their pessimism. Such wistful speculation about the past also beckons to us when we are unhappy with the way the world, or our lives, are going now. “Surely they didn’t have these problems in the good old days, when life was simpler.” Maybe they did not have *exactly* the same problems, but they had problems – and they were most likely worse. Others argue that progress has created new dangers, like bioterrorism or artificial intelligence, that will destroy us. Maybe (I doubt it), but that does not negate the fact of progress. Yes, nuclear weapons *might* end civilization, but until that day life has and will continue to improve. One is a possibility, the other is reality. Knowing the difference between what *might* happen in the future and what *is* happening now is very important. There are so many horrible things that might happen. We shouldn’t ignore them. But the “mights” have a way of crowding out what is. And what is is good. Or at least OK and getting better all the time, which, in the grand scheme of things, is pretty darn good. And yes, I will admit some things are worse about life today than in the past. Pollution, perhaps. Our relative lack of community, perhaps. Our disconnection from, and destruction of, nature. The way technology is creeping into our humanity. There’s more. But I will not condemn the present in favor of the past because of its flaws. If the amazing progress of the After Age has shown us anything, it is that we can solve those, too. At this point, I want to address a couple of specific objections I can imagine you might have. One is about you and the other is about me. The first is, “Yeah, that’s great humanity is doing well, but my life is not.” And the second is, “You are biased. You think things are going great because of who you are, not because that’s how things actually are.” Let me talk about you first. Every argument I’ve made so far is about all of us, on average. I do not know the substance of your life. I do not know if it is secure, comfortable, or healthy. It may not be any of those things. It may be all of them and yet not a happy one. Or your suffering may not be for yourself but for someone you love or care about. I cannot grant you or anyone else happiness merely by showing that the world as a whole is doing better than you thought. The progress of humanity is indifferent to our individual lives and fates. In that sense, we are all just statistics. But there are a couple of things I want you to consider. First, for every problem you or I have today, there is a version of it that is much worse, which, had we been born just a handful of generations earlier, might have been our fate. Some suffering is timeless, but for everything else, we human beings have come up with a pretty good fix, or are at work on one. Second, the fate of the world and your own are connected. I don’t mean the plain fact that if the world has no future you don’t either. I mean they are connected because if the world is improving, then there is good reason to believe that improvement will make its way to you, sooner or later. Humanity has shown a marvelous ability to solve, or at least reduce, the stuff we don’t like, whether it’s a lack of running water or child abuse. The unique problems you, and all of us, might be experiencing today, whether they are as intimate as digital loneliness or as global as climate change, can be conquered by humanity. We’ve beaten worse. Third, simply believing the world has a bright future brightens your present. This is an odd idea and not something we often consider in our me-centered world. But think of it this way: What if you knew for certain humanity will overcome whatever challenges we face today? That whatever the circumstances of your life, it is part of a story of success that started before you were born, and will continue far, far into the future? How would that affect you today? Could it not ease some of the burdens of fear, anxiety, anger, sadness, and need that all of us – rich and poor, healthy and sick, secure and insecure – feel simply by being alive? Certainly not all of it, but at a bare minimum, it would be a nice thing to remember when things aren’t going well for you or me. As I said in the introduction, I did not write this book just for you, I wrote this book for all of us. Thinking of yourself as part of “all of us” is, ironically, how you individually can get the most from this book. Now for your second objection: Who am I to say everything is so great? First, I do not think everything is great. I think everything is OK. There’s a big difference. (Great comes later.) But if you are questioning whether I might be biased, you are correct: I am biased. Very biased. I am a citizen of the United States, and I enjoy the freedoms and privileges that status affords me. Even in one of the wealthiest countries in the world, my wealth is above average. I am white, male, and well-educated. I have no physical handicaps, I suffer from no chronic diseases. I have not personally experienced war, poverty, serious violence or abuse, starvation, meaningful discrimination, or any of the other ills I’ve already mentioned. We are all stuck in our own experience of the world. Mine is different from yours, and everyone else on Earth. I know my optimism is as much a product of my personal experience as it is the reflection of some fundamental truth. If my life had been a harder one, or just different, there’s a decent chance I would not agree with any of this. I’d like to think I still would, but I know that is not how our minds work. I will talk more about this dilemma in the next chapter, because it is central to the rest of this book. But for now let me simply acknowledge my biased point of view, while referring you to the facts I have recited above. Whoever I may or may not be has no bearing on these facts. These include increased wealth, health, peace, freedom, and so on, that human beings have achieved, on average, over time, for hundreds of years now. In other words, you could argue that I am just lucky, and you would be right, but that is precisely my point: In every way it is possible to measure, lucky people like me are more and more common. I don’t just want to be more common though, I want to be average. Actually, I’d love to be below average. I want everyone to enjoy the same benefits of the After Age I have, only more. And I think we can pull it off. In the last 200 years, human life has turned a corner. It has broken free from circumstances that trapped us in the same mode of life for thousands of years, and has begun to move towards a future that is very different. To me, it is clear that this future will be much better than the past, because it already is. But I will admit that it also scares me sometimes. We don’t know where we are headed, except that it will be different from where we came. That is scary. That is why accepting the good news about the present is so important, because it strengthens your optimism about the future. Optimism is not knowing what will happen, but believing that whatever does happen, we can deal with it. I cannot give you 100% certainty that our collective future will be great, or even that it will last beyond tomorrow. There are no guarantees. But I hope I’ve given you reason to believe it can be. You will have to come to your own conclusions. --- Many books about how to change the world start with the assumption that something is fatally flawed with the world as it is now. That is not this book. The world is flawed for sure, but not fatally so. I think we are going to be OK regardless of what I or anyone else does. It isn’t guaranteed, but it’s very likely. I also think that, given our history as a species, OK is pretty good. However, I promised to explain how we could be not just OK, but great. What do I mean by great? I mean expanding the benefits of the After Age to everyone alive, and then going further. Continuing the trends of greater health, wealth, justice, and freedom, and less violence, oppression, and poverty as far as we can reasonably take them. Solving the very real problems introduced in the After Age and undoing the damage we have caused to our planet and ourselves along the way. Securing our future from existential threats. And then...who knows? But we are not there yet. Far from it. In fact, the immediate future is likely to be one of increasing turmoil. Life will continue to improve for us as individuals, on average, over time, in all the ways I have just described. But this is likely to be overshadowed by the heartache those same improvements cause in our societies as a whole. All the money in the world, not to mention all the good health, freedom, and anything else you might value, does not matter if the world around you is a mess. If our societies cannot adapt to the After Age, then no one gets to fully enjoy it. How can we as individuals help our societies deal with the pressure the After Age brings so that we might all pursue greatness? That is what the rest of this book is about. [^1]: Not included is the search for a mate, for complicated reasons. Finding a mate is usually complicated. ## Why Can’t We All Just Get Along? After the pandemic, the other big event of that infamous year, 2020, were the protests that followed the murder of George Floyd, an unarmed Black man, by a police officer. Starting in Minneapolis, where he was killed, the protests and related civil unrest spread across the United States and eventually to dozens of other countries. The murder of Floyd, the protests, the counter-protests, the political fallout, and the eventual conviction of his killer all touch on two of the biggest themes in this book: progress is real, and progress has a destabilizing effect on our societies. The murder of an innocent man may not seem like a good example of progress of any kind. But, as with the example of the pandemic, you have to look for the good news within the bad. And there is good news. The fact that outrage over Floyd’s death definitively crossed racial – and briefly, political – lines. The fact that prosecutors did not engage in the usual stalling tactics in charging the police officers involved, or indeed that they were charged at all. The fact that the protests drew vocal support from governments and organizations around the world and inspired similar movements all over. These facts do show progress in discrimination and racial inequality, even if that progress is simply greater awareness of the problem. But Floyd’s murder also shows the disruptive effects of progress, meaning change. If Black Americans want a change in their status, if they want their lives to matter as much as anyone else’s, that means all Americans have to change, one way or another. We have to change our laws, or our police, or our minds, or likely all of the above. How easy is that to accomplish? That is the unfortunate complication of living in a society: It’s not just about you and what matters to you. It is about all of us. In order for you to get what you want, we all have to cooperate. The more we want – more rights, more peace, more prosperity, more everything – the more we must cooperate. And that is where the problem lies. Or, as another victim of police brutality, Rodney King, once famously asked, “Can’t we all get along?” The answer is not “no.” We do get along, all the time. But the reason we don’t get along better is simple: Getting along, or cooperating, is really, really hard. We have doubled our lifespans, outlawed slavery, invented semiconductors, and walked on the moon. But we have not yet constructed a single human society where people peacefully coexist with each other. It is that hard. We will cure cancer first. We will live to 200 first. We will colonize the solar system first. It is not as if we are overlooking one weird trick, either. There are very good reasons we do not cooperate more. While cooperation in theory is usually considered a good thing, in practice it depends on your point of view. One person’s idea of cooperation might, to someone else, feel like domination, or exploitation, or submission, or manipulation. It is hard to think of any interaction or exchange between human beings that is perfectly equal. Frequently the imbalance is gigantic. Cooperation can be very unfair. And it is hard. As individuals, getting along, or cooperating, may be the most complicated thing any of us do in our lives. It requires more of our time, our patience, our intelligence, and our willpower than anything else. After all, it was the demands of cooperation that drove our evolution out of the animal kingdom, and into this weird in-between space we now exist in, no longer wild animals yet still behaving like them far too often. Cooperation is humility and recognizing your own insignificance. Cooperation is making the effort to understand – and even harder, *to* *value* – someone else’s point of view, and in so doing letting go of your own. Cooperation is doing the right thing even when others do not, and yet benefit from your sacrifice. Cooperation poses an existential dilemma for all of us as individuals, as groups, and as a species. Are we individuals, or are we part of something larger than ourselves? And if we’re both, which comes first? And just how widely does that “something larger” apply? We struggle with these questions every day, whether we realize it or not. But for all its pains, cooperation is totally worth it. Cooperation is what powers everything great about the After Age, and indeed every age. If we want to be more successful – healthier, richer, more peaceful, secure, and free to live, do, and say what we want, and not just some of us but all of us – we must cooperate more and better than we ever have before. Given how hard and burdensome cooperating is, it should not be surprising that there is stiff resistance to doing more of it. Nationalistic, xenophobic, sectarian, and ethnocentric movements around the world are just some examples of resistance to greater cooperation. The denial of collective responsibility for various problems, climate change being the biggest example, is another. You may be surprised to learn, however, that so is opposition to globalization and free trade, increased governmental power and reach, and cultural assimilation. Those are all examples of how we cooperate for our mutual benefit, some of them more controversial than others. I have a great deal of sympathy for anyone resisting pressure to cooperate more. It is entirely rational to resist any process where you, or your people, give up something with little or no immediate benefit. Everyone, sooner or later, finds the demands of greater cooperation unpleasant, unfair, or unacceptable, myself included. And yet, we don’t really have a choice. The After Age has unleashed forces that are prodding us together, forcing us to cooperate more and in ways that push the limits of the cooperation we have already achieved (which, to be fair to the human race, is pretty impressive for a bunch of ex-monkeys). I will talk more about these forces in the chapters that follow, but the bottom line is that while we can resist and delay them for a while, sooner or later we have to figure out a way to adapt. In other words, we can be dragged into the future kicking and screaming, or we can stride towards it with grace and finesse. Given what I know about the human race, I think it’s safe to predict it will be mostly kicking and screaming, and not much grace and finesse. But even a little more grace is very, very valuable. It is the difference between millions of lives lost or saved. And it could make the difference between infinite success and permanent failure. In the chapters that follow, I will provide you with some perspective on why these pressures are occurring, and actionable ideas for how you can cope with and benefit from them while also contributing positively to the world around you. I start with the self, and then expand outwards to other people and groups, then other countries, and then abstract ideas like government, money, and more. But always the ideas are meant for you as an individual; I’m not suggesting how our nations or governments or world should change, just how you can change the way you think about them. You may find some of the ideas that follow controversial. I often assume the worst about human behavior. I assume we are often selfish, biased, greedy, violent, shortsighted, and tribal, and that this is unlikely to change. That does not mean we cannot be great, however. While I am a pessimist about many things, I am an optimist about the big stuff. I think we have a great future ahead of us, but we’ve got to be honest about our flaws first. For that reason, many of my suggestions are very pragmatic. They are not about us being our best selves, but just good enough. Another reason you may find what follows controversial is that, as I have just explained, cooperation often is. In the first chapter that follows, I write about how individuals can be more cooperative in a way that is likely to cause strong disagreement in some people. In the next, I jump from the frying pan into the fire by discussing cooperation between groups and, specifically, the topics of social diversity and prejudice. Always tricky territory. I am not setting out to offend anyone, and I have taken care not to, but I might anyway. Apologies in advance. Finally, I need to make an important point which is critical to the rest of this book. As I mentioned in the previous chapter, I have many biases, and those biases influence the ideas I present here. Pointing out a person’s bias, especially based on their ethnic background, gender, class, and other demographic features, has become a common criticism in debate over many of the topics covered in this book. This type of criticism can be traced back to the intellectual movement known as postmodernism. As a general definition, postmodernism considers “universal” ideas like truth, reason, and progress as made-up justifications for political or economic power. Taken to an extreme, postmodernism strips all objective meaning and fact from every idea. Everything becomes relative, nothing is real. Postmodernism, taken too far, is responsible for a lot of nonsense. However, the underlying insight of postmodernism – that what we think is truth may be a product of our own point of view, or an accident of history – is not nonsense. It is, in fact, urgently important and (ironically) profoundly true. It is key to solving the knotty problem of cooperation, and thus it is one of the themes of this book. We have entered an exciting period of human history. The 500-year dominance of Western nations and Western peoples is coming to an end. The 10,000-year dominance of men over women is, too. Those are just a couple of the most obvious examples of power structures and social patterns that are likely to fall, or transform, in the coming decades and centuries. Meanwhile, communications technology has allowed everyone to have a voice that can reach anyone else. New opinions and new points of view are growing louder. Things are kind of up in the air right now. Relativity and uncertainty are a truth for our time. In other words, we live in a postmodern world. I am a postmodernist. And if you aren’t one yet, I hope you will become at least a little postmodern yourself after reading this book. Being aware of your own bias, or to put it less critically, your own point of view, is probably the best advice I can give you for helping us all to be great. A version of this advice runs through every chapter that follows. It is advice I take to heart. For me writing this book, it was a constant presence, like a voice over my shoulder saying “Are you sure?” and “How do you know?” and “Who are you to say?” I take that voice very seriously. However, as you can see, that voice has not stopped me from making some very sweeping statements about the entire human race. That is because I believe we still need those universal ideas, ideas that could apply to all of us, now more than ever, precisely because so much is now wide open. It is one of the paradoxes of the After Age. Our postmodern world makes it much harder to find ideas we can all share, while at the same time making that search all the more important. Whether they are the old ideas, reinterpreted, or new ones, we need them. That search requires more patience, more humility, and more work than it ever has. It is an intergenerational, intergroup, and international effort. This book is my contribution to it. # Part: Widening Circles of Concern ## You You are the greatest accomplishment of the After Age. By “you” I mean the modern individual. Of course, in a literal sense, individuality was not invented in the After Age, or any other time. The moment you exit your mama’s womb, you are an individual. But only recently in human history have you, and your individual opinions, pursuits, rights, and property had any objective importance. They are protected by law, and they are recognized, respected, nurtured, and encouraged by society. If you live in the After Age, your individuality exists, it matters, and it is defended and respected more than ever before. In fact, today, we are so free and so empowered we assume we don’t have any obligations to society at all, beyond paying taxes and obeying laws. Or perhaps I should phrase it differently: It is not that we assume we have no obligations to society, it is that we assume society does not need anything from us. If all we want is to be OK, that may be true. But if we are to go from OK to great, then it is not. Individual freedom and rights are awesome. I wouldn’t trade them for the world and I would defend them with my life. But what follows moves in a different direction. Having been discovered, cherished, protected, and promoted vigorously in the After Age, it is now time for the individual to start thinking about everyone else for a change. Where it concerns you, the individual, and your place in the society around you, it’s time for a bit of a correction. The truth is, the After Age does not ask that much of us individuals in return for quite a lot. Technology allows us to be very independent with little effort. Tasks that in the past would have required weeks of organization and work can be done with the push of a button. We do not have to plow the fields for months to grow a meager amount of food, or organize the help of dozens of other people to erect a home, send a letter, or travel across the country. All of these things can be obtained from a vast system already in place, humming along, ready to fulfill our wish and command. Machines, better organization, and anonymous others spread across the planet collaborate to deliver what we want. Compared to the effort once required, all of the tasks of life are, in the After Age, relatively effortless. Freer and more equal government and societies do not burden us like those of the past did, either. In the After Age we are not required to bow to our social betters or limit the clothes we wear or what we say or believe. Government is less threatening, as its ability to control what we can or cannot be or do or think or say has been gradually chipped away. To be clear, we are fre*er* and *more* equal – not perfectly free or totally equal. But the magnitude of the change that has occurred is enormous. If we don’t feel it is because that is not how we experience life. Our perspective is narrow and focussed on our own in the moment, not in comparison to what was or might have been. But we need that wider perspective. If you live in the After Age you are among a lucky minority of all the human beings that have ever lived. It is so important that the rest of humanity, today and in the future, join you there. It is equally important that you and your descendants remain there. What can you do to help ensure that happens? The After Age is making demands on us as individuals all the time. You can ignore them. Or you can start listening, and learn from what you hear, and by doing so empower yourself to make the most of the world we live in. ### Stop taking us for granted. Never have we had so many relationships in our lives. True, most of them are trivial: the customer I sell a cell phone plan to; the sales clerk that sells it to me. The fellow employee who sends a machine part, legal document, resume, or shipping container your way, and the other employee you send it off to when you’ve done your job. The anonymous people behind the internet store that make, sell, and ship to you clothes, appliances, food, or who knows what – and the anonymous people that purchase the stuff you make, sell, market, and otherwise push out into the world. You and them may be in the same town or on opposite sides of the planet. You may never meet in person, and may never communicate directly at all. These relationships are very weak compared to our relationships with our families or friends. And they are mostly economic in nature. But there are an awful lot of them. An enormous amount of them. A staggering amount of them. Never before have we been tied to so many other people, all over the world. Individually, each tie is weak, easily broken, and brief. But together they are a dense web spreading out from every single one of us, and we depend on that web to survive, and to thrive. Every aspect of our modern lives, what makes the After Age such a miracle of human progress, is absolutely dependent on this web of relationships. We really do depend on people hundreds or thousands of miles away for our food, shelter, power, medicine – everything. Without those connections, those relationships, weak though they may be, many of us would quickly die. And we are more and more dependent on them every day. Let me be clear: This is not a bad thing. Personally, I find the idea that I am connected to so many people around the world awe-inspiring. The After Age is constructed out of the dense interconnections, both in space and time, of billions of people and their actions in the world. Like all awe-inspiring things, it is a little scary. But if you’ve thought about it enough to be scared by its immensity, then you can also be inspired. You have been born into this wonderful *thing* that can deliver what would have once been considered miracles, and do it on a regular basis. This web of connections is incredibly powerful and empowering. But it does require us to change the way we think about ourselves and the world around us. As individuals living in the After Age, it is our job to respect, support, and maintain these relationships. It is one of the few things that modern societies truly need from us as individuals. We have been given once-unimaginable freedom and wealth, but to support that freedom and wealth, we must tend to the web of relationships that make it possible. The good news is it is not that difficult to do your part. ### Humility is a reality and a virtue. Humility is a modest view of your own importance. This happens to be an accurate description of reality: You are not that important. I am not trying to put you down, just pointing out the obvious. Here’s one way to think about it: There are nearly eight billion human beings alive on Earth, as of this writing. If all of us stood shoulder to shoulder in a line, and you drove past us going 55 miles an hour, it would take you over *four years* of continuous driving, day and night, to reach the last person. That’s a lot of people. Nearly eight billion people living their own lives, pursuing their own individual wants and needs, making their way through the 24 hours in each day we all share. Compared to this collective ocean of human activity, the needs and desires of one person don’t amount to a hill of beans. Individual humility is the only honest reaction to this reality. Humility is not necessary just because it is true, however. Humility is necessary because it helps us as individuals to see and accept the enormousness and complexity of this ocean of humanity we find ourselves in. If we live in the After Age, chances are we live in a society and country that is diverse, technologically advanced, and economically complex. It is interconnected within itself and with the rest of the world in ways no one can fully understand or measure. Life in the After Age is not on the scale of the individual, and yet we individuals are pulled into it, and must swim with its currents, whether we like it or not. Because of this, the After Age demands flexibility and understanding from us. We cannot possibly expect that the world should be shaped to serve us alone. We certainly cannot act that way. Humility is the best way to achieve that acceptance. A little humility – that is all that is necessary or appropriate, a little – does not require dramatic changes in our behavior or even any change in our behavior at all. It is first and foremost a different way of looking at the world and our place in it. Humility is an acknowledgment that our needs, wants, opinions, desires, possessions, priorities, history, culture, family, friends, business, race, religion, politics, gender, fashion, language, investments, job, favorite color, and everything else that matters to us cannot possibly be all that matters. If humility does change our behavior, it is by allowing us to consider the wants, needs, and viewpoints of others when pursuing our own. We accept and respect that others have their own reality, their own points of view, and we try to accommodate them. When you realize you cannot be the only person that matters in the world, you gain a new perspective on what really matters to you. Being a little humble doesn't mean you as an individual don’t matter. We all matter, at the very least to ourselves (I hope), and likely to many other people. In fact, to live in the After Age means to live somewhere where your individual worth is protected by law. The legally recognized inalienable worth of every individual is one of the most hard-won and valuable achievements of the last 200 years, and we should never give it up, for anything. Instead, by not taking this gift for granted, we are then more willing to graciously bend our individual identity and rights to the needs of the society around us for all of our benefit. Our absolute importance as individuals is large, but our relative importance is small compared to the massive whole of which we are a teeny tiny part. That is one of the paradoxes we must live with in the After Age. A little humility is a central trade-off for the individual in the After Age: In exchange for a future of peace, prosperity, and stability, we accept our own lesser importance relative to the whole. By doing so, we become more willing to forego some of our needs and desires in exchange for things that benefit everyone, including ourselves. ### Your individual beliefs are just some of billions. Given how many different, and often conflicting points of view there are in the world, it is unlikely that all, or even most, of your own could possibly be correct, if such a thing as “correct” even exists. It is not necessary to be humble to realize this, but it helps. Certainly, acknowledging that you are likely wrong about some things makes humility easier. This does not mean that we should suppress or ignore our beliefs and opinions. Rather, humility means both believing something to be true, and at the same time accepting the fact that millions of other people appear to believe something very different. A willingness to hold conflicting ideas like this in your head while continuing to function is a requirement of life in the After Age, and is something I will bring up again and again in this book. (It also encourages humility.) You know chocolate is best, yet so many prefer vanilla. How is that possible? Maybe those who prefer vanilla are deluded and evil, or maybe the world is a mysterious, complex place and you can’t possibly understand it completely (Indeed, you may not even understand yourself completely: maybe you like vanilla, too). You and those who disagree with you are expected to share the same world, if not the same country, if not the same street, if not the same building, if not the same apartment in that building, and get along well enough to avoid killing each other, at a bare minimum. How? I recommend a little humility. Preference for chocolate or vanilla may seem like a trivialization of the differences of opinion that divide us. But if you accept that other points of view exist and are not going away, then what that point of view is is, on one level, irrelevant. It might as well be chocolate versus vanilla. This is not about which is correct, or what course of action society should take. I am not saying there are no right or wrong opinions, or at least better or worse, about many, many things. There are. But right now, what I am talking about is you and me, as individuals, coexisting with others, when we have no power over how they think or what they believe. Chocolate vs. vanilla. Some might argue that even acknowledging the existence of another point of view, let alone contemplating the possibility that it is valid or even better than your own, weakens your convictions. I agree, it does weaken your convictions. You become more uncertain compared to those who are absolutely sure. This is a good thing. Conviction without humility is a dangerous charade. Dare to see the world from another person’s point of view. Do it alone, in private, if you must. But do it. It is terrifying and exhilarating and enlightening and fun. But more importantly, it is necessary. Anyway, if you can’t do it voluntarily, you will be forced to do so soon enough. Get your practice in now – you’re going to need it. Some might also argue that being humble or even-handed about some subject where there is, or appears to be, an obvious right and wrong position is a mistake, that it is accommodating evil. All I can say is if something is truly intolerable, you’ll know because you won’t be able to stand it, not with all the humility in the world. That is one good thing about injustice: sooner or later it forces the issue. ### Merely get along. The prosperity of the After Age is utterly dependent on a network of relationships between people all over the world, most of whom will never meet. As mere individuals in a sea of humanity, our influence on the whole is very, very small. But it is still there, and, of course, combined with everyone else’s it is immense. You still have a part to play. One thing we can do to contribute to our mutual well-being is to get along with the people we do encounter. This means both people we come into contact with directly, and those we only interact with in passing or from far away. By making the effort to get along with other people, even in the most casual, brief, or superficial interactions, we help keep the whole healthy and strong. Make way for other people, rather than force them to make way for you. Yield. If the society around you is a web, you want to be a strand, not a pebble thrown into it. This advice is so bland, so obvious, and yet so important. We all know we should be kind to strangers, hold the door open, say please and thank you, all that other stuff they taught you in grade school. But I want to remind you of it again, this time in the context of the After Age and The Destiny of the Entire Human Race. Your mom told you being polite matters. I am telling you the fate of the world depends on it. While it seems like an effort to accommodate other people, especially people very different from you – and it is – in some ways it is more of an effort not to. Coexistence requires effort, but nothing like the friction generated when people are indifferent or hostile to each other. Take the example of traffic rules. We stop at stop signs and traffic lights, we drive on one side of the road but not the other and we (more or less) obey speed limits. All of these things make driving more complicated and more work. But if everyone ignored traffic rules, no one would get anywhere. All the individual rights and freedoms in the world do not change the fact that the best outcome is one where the individual and society coexist without harm coming to either. And while we are individuals who can decide and choose for ourselves, society is just a big, dumb thing that only exists because we have willed it into being. It relies on us to do the work of cooperation. Urging individuals to “just get along” has a bad reputation because it can be used to defend unfair, oppressive, or destructive conditions. If you are fighting for your rights in a society that refuses to recognize them, then you should not try to get along. Deliberately not getting along, deliberately not being in harmony with those around you, is how every improvement in the value of the individual has been won. It is a choice made by people seeking to make the world a better place. That does not make conflict or turmoil good or desirable, however. It is another contradiction of the After Age that a peaceful and harmonious society may only be achieved by doing the opposite, at least some of the time. Only by first understanding the value of society, by cherishing it, by humbling yourself to it, can you make it better. But if you do not value society to begin with, then you are not trying to make it better by disrupting it. You’re just trying to destroy it. But let’s face it: Most of us are not fighting to make the world a better place. We are living for ourselves, our families maybe, our friends possibly, our jobs perhaps. We have no excuse for not making an effort to live in harmony with everyone else. When you pursue your own goals without any concern for how they will affect the people around you, that is an act of nihilism. If everyone acts that way, the After Age ends. Maybe I am alone in this, but one of the greatest pleasures I get from being in the world is pleasant encounters with strangers and minor acquaintances. The more different from each other we are, the more pleasure I get from peacefully interacting with them. This stuff, this petty intercourse between anonymous human beings, is what makes the world go round. There is no substitute for it, no way to fake it, or force it. Either it happens or it does not, and whether it does is all in the hands of each one of us, every day. ### Get some perspective on your suffering. I can show how far humanity has come in the last 200 years. I can argue that we live much longer, healthier lives, have more personal freedom and legal rights, and are better educated and less violent, among a host of other improvements. I can prove that we have achieved things that our ancestors would not even know how to dream about, and do so on a daily basis. And yet, I am not sure we are happier than they were. I believe we are, but not as much as we should be, given the improvements in our lives. Civilization has leapt forward, but it can seem quite underwhelming to those of us living in it. The problem is we are never satisfied, even when we get what we think we want. It’s just not how we are wired. And if we never earned these luxuries to begin with, if we were born with them, then we truly take them for granted, and our expectations are reset higher and higher. If we have enough food to eat, we complain that our diet lacks variety. If we can choose our leaders, we complain when our choice isn’t the one that wins. If we can travel farther in one day than our ancestors did in their entire lives, we complain about the traffic or the lines at the airport, or are jealous of the people traveling first class. These things don’t just make us annoyed, either. We can get genuinely, profoundly unhappy in circumstances that would seem luxurious to others and miraculous to those that came before us. What happens is that profound suffering – starvation, violence, serious disease, oppression – occurs to us individually less, or not at all, but our capacity to feel mental suffering stays the same. We become stressed or anxious about difficulties or challenges that are not even close to being serious, let alone life-threatening, yet we allow them to fill nearly as much space in our minds. Or, in a similar way, we see what other people have and we feel bad because we have less – even though we have more than was once thought possible. This happens to me all the time. In the After Age, most people are unhappy not because they are experiencing profound suffering. They are unhappy because they don’t have the job or lover or house they wanted and someone else does, or because they aren’t getting along with the people around them, or because they are worried about things that have not happened, but might, or because they heard about something bad that happened far away that they have no control over and does not directly affect them in any way but are nonetheless anxious about. Or, most frequently, because of vague and conflicting yearnings, desires, regrets, confusions, and bad memories that make them uneasy, moody, depressed, dissatisfied, angry, etc., etc. You are probably one of those people. I am definitely one of those people. As William Shakespeare’s most famous character said, “there is nothing either good or bad, but thinking makes it so.” While that is not 100% true, Hamlet had a point. Especially when you have plenty of food to eat, live in a climate-controlled home filled with entertainment devices, and will live twice as long as your ancestors. Which is nearly everyone in the After Age, a group of people that numbers in the billions and is growing every day. The only way you could possibly remain unhappy for a sustained period in those circumstances is if you think your way into that state, which is exactly what we do. It is true that some sources of unhappiness may be unique to the After Age. We live longer, but suffer more in old age (maybe). We can travel and communicate across vast distances, but we are lonely because we’ve lost touch with the people next door. We have more than enough to eat, so we eat too much and get heart disease or diabetes. We create amazing stuff, but we destroy the environment doing so. And so on. Clearly, the After Age is not all rainbows and ice cream. Clearly, we have work to do. It is also true that this is a vast generalization. I am guessing about the content of your life based on an average. I have no way to know and no right to judge the hardship of your life. Only you can say if any of this applies to you. But whether it does or not, it is still relevant. Regardless of the circumstances of your life, our collective tendency to be dissatisfied with our lives – no matter how good we have it, objectively speaking – will continue. As citizens of the After Age, we need to be aware of this short-sighted tendency of ours so we can do our part to reduce its negative consequences. One thing you can do to help is to not project your problems onto the world at large and then conclude it is hopelessly corrupt and going to hell. The world is not going to hell. It is going in the opposite direction. If you’ve read this far, you ought to understand that by now. Even global warming, the ultimate, literal going-to-hell scenario, would have to get very, very, *very* bad to outweigh all the improvements in human life over the last 200 years. I am not going to guarantee global warming won’t get that bad, but it is highly unlikely. When we start thinking everything is falling apart, one frequent reaction is to devalue what we have already. We mentally prepare for (incorrectly) predicted disaster by giving up on the present. Once that happens, we become open to extreme, drastic, risky, and foolish decisions in our politics and behavior. We become like the desperate man who spends his last dollars at the casino. Collectively, this attitude can be disastrous. When enough of us forget how much we have to be thankful for, we stop defending it. When we stop defending it, we may lose it. Let’s not lose it. The other thing you can do to help is remind yourself how lucky you are to live in the After Age. To keep going and expand to include everyone, the After Age requires some sacrifice, voluntary or otherwise, from those who already enjoy its privileges. Having some perspective on your own suffering (or lack of it) helps to make this burden easier to bear. As I have pointed out earlier, accepting that the world is not falling to pieces can also have a positive impact on our own life and personal happiness. No one enjoys living in a place they think has no future. Let the very real and continuing improvements of the After Age inform your view of the world, and uplift it. ### Don’t mistake selfishness for greatness. Humility, modesty, compromise, “getting along”. These values are not inspiring, noble, or heroic. No one ever says, “when I grow up, I want to be a humble and productive member of society!” This is especially true for my fellow Americans. Humility is not a virtue in this country. It’s not how we are raised or the kind of behavior we have been taught to respect. We make heroes out of people who stormed through the world, living their lives how they wanted. Those people are entertaining if nothing else. We admire them for the impact they had on the world, or what they did for themselves. Their stories are inspiring, and they fuel the desire all of us have to be recognized by other people as deserving of praise and admiration. I am not going to dispute the charm or value of individual accomplishment. But I want to throw up a warning flag: Just because these things are awesome for the individual involved, and entertaining or inspiring for the rest of us, does not mean they are not also in conflict with a healthy society. The problem here is that because we so often see selfishness associated with greatness, we assume selfishness is great, too. It is not. We all act for ourselves, there’s nothing remarkable about it. But the people who do amazing things for themselves very often can do them precisely because they do not care about other people or society at large. It is often their extreme indifference to others that allows them to pursue extreme greatness. We might think that only people like that – strong-willed, relentless, single-minded – can change the world for the better. We might think that the only way to accomplish things is by battering through the society around you. Which may be true, some of the time. But there is another way to accomplish things, and in fact a much more common one: Cooperation. That is, compromising your individual desires to contribute to a greater whole. Furthermore, is it not equally true that such people, once they have power, are often exactly the ones standing in the way? We have seen, over and over in history, what happens when such people gain control over societies through government. They start to destroy them, and if not not stopped, they succeed. Similar egoism has a similar effect on organizations of all kinds. In the After Age, so much good has been created by people peacefully cooperating, rather than favoring themselves at the expense of others. To upend such a world you need a really good reason. Personal glory is not one. We all have the urge to stand out from the crowd, to accomplish “great” things. I am not trying to convince you to do otherwise. Everyone is a mix of motivations and desires, selfish and selfless. In us humans, the drive to help other people or create beautiful things is inseparable from our desire for personal glory and recognition. After all, personal glory is one reason I wrote this book. (I’d like to think I would have written it anyway, but who knows.) This advice is for you and I. You and I are unlikely to ever be so “great” that we could threaten the stability of our society or the After Age. (If you think you might, go for it. YOLO, right?) This is about what we humble, everyday people value not just in our leaders but in ourselves. When we glorify selfishness, it shows up in our own behavior and the way we treat other people in our humble, everyday lives (whether we want to see them that way or not). I urge you to consider where most of the glory lies, indeed where most of life is. You could dream of having your face chiseled into a mountain top, literally or figuratively. Or you could aspire to live the life you want that is also in harmony with the people around you, and then, in a sense, the whole world is your monument. ### Those who get along best, win. This book aims to provide advice and insight that benefits both the individual and society at the same time. This next tip however is excellent advice for you whether it benefits society or not. It is an open secret, never more true than today, that the better you get along with other people, the more success in life you will have. Those with the most friends and acquaintances receive the most rewards. They rise fastest in the diverse human organizations that populate every corner of our lives. They learn of new opportunities the earliest. They gather networks of supporters, and those supporters isolate their enemies and lift them up with them. We are the descendants of those who got along best with others, and this trait has never been more of an advantage than it is today. ## Everyone Else If you live in the After Age, chances are you live in a society with a greater amount of diversity than it has ever had before. Because of economic and technological changes, people who were once separated by thousands of miles – and unaware of each other’s existence, appearance, behavior, culture, and beliefs – find themselves living next door to each other, doing business together, or otherwise in contact. This is not new, but the frequency and degree to which it is happening in the After Age is shocking. But our diversity in the After Age is not just about once distant peoples bumping into each other because of immigration or trade. Diversity grows from within as well. The hard-earned freedom and equality of the After Age mean anyone is freer to choose a life and lifestyle that is better for them, instead of what is expected based on history or custom. Our freedom to be who we want to be is increasing differences within societies even without immigration. Cooperation among human beings, individually and in groups, is the foundation upon which the progress of the After Age is built. Its future depends on that cooperation continuing, if not increasing. Rising diversity is a serious challenge to this because of the friction it causes between groups of people. In a nutshell, it is harder to cooperate with people who are not like you. The problem of other people, and other people’s people, must be acknowledged, confronted, and overcome, or at least made manageable, if the full potential of the After Age is to be fulfilled. The good news is that successfully managing this problem is 100% possible. Indeed, we are already doing an OK job of it – not great, but OK. We just need to get better at it. For better or worse, we are going to get plenty of practice. In the sections that follow, I will provide you with some new ways of thinking about diversity, what it is, how to live with it, and how to manage the related problem of prejudice in your own behavior. These ideas are meant to be actionable, practical tools for living in diverse societies, not solutions. They treat both our growing diversity and our imperfect response to it as facts of life, ones that are not going away, whether we want them to or not. We do not need to be perfect to be great. ### Our diversity is a burden on all of us. Diversity is not, of itself, good or bad. It is simply a quality of things. A diverse bag of marbles, a diverse menu, a diverse group of people. Diversity is, furthermore, a relative quality. It is possible for the same group of people to be very diverse according to one point of view, and not at all by another. Finally, diversity is a moving target. As our perception of what is and is not a meaningful difference between people changes, our opinion of what constitutes diversity does as well. On an individual basis, our own awareness of group differences changes all the time, or fades away completely. However, diversity within a society is a burden, especially diversity from the three biggest dividers of humanity: race/ethnicity, religion, and language/culture. These divisions and others create unequal treatment, miscommunication, tension, suspicion, jealousy, and resentment that reduce trust and cooperation and even lead to violence. This in turn can weaken a society’s ability to perform its responsibilities and maintain itself. Again: There’s nothing new here. We have been behaving this way since before we were human beings. We are, and we will be, OK despite it. But greatness requires a bit more consideration of the issue, from all of us. There are a few ways societies deal with this problem, which I will simplify into three basic approaches: One, they don’t have this problem, or not much, because they are not very diverse. Two, they reduce diversity by expelling or eliminating part of their population. And three, they learn to accept their diversity and still function – indeed, to flourish. The first option is either available or not. If you live in a relatively non-diverse place, congratulations, you don’t have to deal with the burden of diversity. Everyone's the same. Yay. At least, for right now – but see the introduction to this section. Also, I would double check with the people around you. “Your people” may be more diverse than you think. The second option is, historically, very popular, despite the fact that it is obviously immoral, and is destructive not only to the targeted group but to the rest of the population as well. It has all the drawbacks that violence and destruction have always had. Also, you have to be successful in expelling or eliminating the targeted group, or you end up with a permanently fractured and embittered population at war with itself. And of course, any survivors of your purge will now be your enemy, wherever they end up. Nonetheless, it remains very popular because it is simple to understand and easy to act on. The third option is typically where societies end up after the first option is gone and the second has failed. It is really the only option and always has been. It is also the only road to greatness, even if it appears at first to be an unhappy, mediocre compromise. That road begins with acceptance: acceptance of diversity, and of the inescapable burden it brings. Accepting that diversity burdens society, and by extension, you, is essential. Diversity’s burden may weigh heavy or light depending on the circumstances and depending on your point of view and lived experience. But to pretend it does not exist is dangerous. Pretending there is no burden does not allow for the possibility of easing that burden, since there is no point addressing a problem that you don’t believe exists. Accepting that diversity burdens society does not mean rejecting diversity and it certainly does not mean diversity is bad or should be eliminated. In fact, the opposite: Diversity is who we are, and we should embrace it. But we should be honest about its drawbacks, too. There are many things that inconvenience us or make our lives more difficult but that we nonetheless accept as part of life. Indeed, accepting diversity, despite its burdens, is to live by one of the fundamental agreements of the After Age: By making the effort to allow others to live their lives the way they wish, you best guarantee that they will do the same for you. Everything good in the After Age comes from our ability to cooperate and coexist with each other. Even better things are likely if we can extend that cooperation beyond old boundaries of race, religion, and so on. Remember how much convenience the After Age has brought us, like longer lives, more freedom, and greater material comfort and safety, and then ask whether its burdens are really so much to bear. ### Resistance to diversity is one of the burdens of diversity. To have an identity is to have an identity to defend. We fear people who are different from us entering our society and changing it. This is true when people cross a geographical border. But it is also true when people cross a social border, some rule or boundary we have set up in our societies for what is considered acceptable behavior. Where these borders lie is different for everyone. But for each of us, when they are crossed, we feel threatened. To put it a different way, resistance to social change is a feature of every society, because it is a feature of every person. Everyone has their boundaries they don’t like to see crossed, an understanding of their world they do not want changed or disrupted. Our fear is not irrational, either. Society matters. Community, shared culture, shared identity, these things matter to human beings, whoever we are. They are intrinsically valuable to everyone who is allowed to enjoy them. And, as I have explained, diversity burdens this valuable shared identity. If we did not react when this identity was threatened, what would be the point of having it in the first place? Ironically, this resistance to diversity is one thing that unites us as human beings. Over the years I have been writing this book there has been a rise in nationalistic, sectarian, and other ethnocentric movements in democracies around the world. It is a worrying trend. But it is also oddly comforting, because it underlines how much we all have in common. Every country and people in the world is under pressure from an increasingly crowded, interconnected world. Hardening one’s identity – racial, religious, national, or whatever – is a common reaction to this universal insecurity, like a turtle retreating into its shell. It is not the most constructive response, and certainly not the most sustainable long-term. But it is very familiar. Its frequency around the world reminds me that we are all very alike, which in turn gives me hope we can eventually move past this initial reaction towards better cooperation. In other words, by being so consistent in the way we insist on the differences between us, we bind ourselves closer together as a species, even as we try to drive ourselves apart. It becomes more difficult to see one instance of intergroup hatred as a unique expression of specific circumstances, and more like a chronic problem with the human condition that needs to be dealt with in a practical manner, for example in the way we deal with sewage, or traffic, or infectious disease. If you feel your ethnic, national, religious, or some other identity is under threat, I hope you will consider how universal, and generic, your defensive emotions are before getting all up in arms about it – figuratively, or literally. The fact that this is behavior shared by everyone else, including members of the group(s) you feel are threatening *you*, not to mention many senseless animal species as well, should make you reconsider your motivations. Are you really motivated by the love and defense of your unique, special, and glorious motherland, people, or creed? Might it instead be something more primitive and simple? From there you might start thinking about what, exactly, you are so angry, frightened, or defensive about to begin with. The borders around our identities change all the time. And yet we defend them, sometimes violently, as if they were eternally fixed in place. How does that make any sense? On the other hand, for anyone who condemns those described above for their behavior, I would ask: Are you sure you would never do the same? Are you sure you haven’t already? The remarkable similarity of divisive ethnic, sectarian, political and other movements around the world should make anyone who thinks they would never engage in such behavior think twice. Clearly, this is in our nature. Somewhere in you is the potential to do the same. Given the pressure we are all under this century, there’s a decent chance you will live up to that potential. Rather than thinking of bigotry or xenophobia as something other people do, start thinking of it as one of the burdens that our diversity places on all of us. We need that acceptance. We cannot choose the parts of human nature that we want, we have to take it all. We must learn to live with the flaws of human nature, and yet create a better future than the past. And we have. Just because diversity burdens our shared identities does not mean we must choose between the two. That is the paradox here, yet another we must live with in the After Age. ### Where everyone bends, no one has to break. Our diversity burdens society and each other. Showing that you are aware of this burden, and bearing your part of it, goes a long way towards easing it. Bearing the burden of diversity means changing your behavior and your life to accommodate it. How exactly we change depends on who we are and where we live. But the principle is the same everywhere: We must bend towards each other so that none of us must break. To bend means to demonstrate that you are aware of another person or people, and are willing to accommodate them, and indeed inconvenience yourself in doing so, even if only in a small or temporary way. In exchange, we should expect, and demand, the freedom to otherwise live our lives the way we see fit. It is a worthwhile trade, I think. Making the effort necessary to get along, that is, to bend towards others, is generally more important to other people than the language you speak, the religion you practice, or the color of your skin. It is the greatest signal of respect for people different from you because we all know it takes effort. Making an effort to accommodate another person who is different from you can, if only for a moment, eclipse hundreds of years of hatred. You might think that does not matter, but it is these brief moments between individuals that make up the fabric of society, and determine its fate. I won’t pretend this burden falls equally on everyone all of the time. But the inequity of the burden does not negate the principle itself. If we believe in our society, we carry our individual responsibility to support it regardless of what others might or might not do. Is that unfair? Some of the time, yes. (I said cooperation was difficult and unfair.) Our present and future greatness is about the many of us who accept this burden, not the few who do not. If enough of us do, the bickering of those that do not will be drowned out, like a kind of herd immunity. Indeed it may be the acceptance of this obligation, or not, that most clearly divides the people of the After Age today and will most closely predict its future. If the idea of people “bending towards each other” sounds vague, unrealistic, or naive, you are not paying attention to the world around you. Most people are doing this all the time. From the moment we entered this world, we have been trained to get along with others. When we do, it feels good. Certainly, it is not the only thing that drives us, but its power cannot be denied. In fact, its power is equal to, if not greater than, our fear and suspicion of each other. Just because this instinct and training can be distracted by minor differences or passing emotions does not negate its power. While fear and suspicion are a fire that must be fed, our ability to cooperate is like the grass that grows beneath our feet: unnoticed, unremarked upon, but ceaseless, tenacious, and self-perpetuating. We trample it, and yet it keeps growing back. In other words, when we are not tearing down our societies, we are ceaselessly building them up, usually without even noticing. It should be assumed that the process of bending towards each other will mean some sacrifice from all of us. It is not neutral. It is changing us and changing our societies. We are bending towards something, even if that new standard is not fully defined. Things will be, and have been, lost. New things emerge. New rules of behavior, new obligations, new rituals, new taboos. This is not surprising: The After Age is a new thing, too, and it is still creating itself. But the core things we value from our societies and from other people will not disappear, even if they are temporarily obscured by change. Human beings build societies like a bird builds a nest: we use whatever we have at hand. If what we have is a diverse group of people, then that is the material we will use to create our society. But the nest still serves the same purpose it always has. ### Accept your hypocrisy. There are two sets of moral rules each of us carry around in our heads. Rules about what is right and wrong, fair and unfair, reasonable and unreasonable. One set is for people like us. The other set is for everyone else. The reason is simple: Some people matter more to us than others. When bad things happen to one of Us we are filled with compassion. When the same bad things happen to one of Them we have less compassion, or are indifferent, or worse, we figure they deserved it for some reason. When one of Them commits an atrocious act, it is a crime. When one of Us does the exact same thing, it is completely justified. We are all hypocrites. Some people would say this is not hypocrisy, but simply what it means to be part of a group. I agree. Also, it is hypocrisy. If you live in the After Age, you benefit enormously from the principle, enshrined in government, in law, and in the unspoken fabric of our culture, that every person matters and is, on some level, worthy of equal treatment. Yet when it comes to how we live our lives, some people matter more than others. That sounds pretty hypocritical to me! In diverse societies this hypocrisy is a universal discomfort, one everyone must struggle with every day. We share a society, a nation, and a planet. We are expected to live alongside each other, to be in some sense one. And yet we are not – not at all. How is that supposed to work? One way to deal with it is to embrace a view of the world where only some people matter. This standpoint is at least not hypocritical, as long as you stop believing in everything else that brought us to this miraculous moment in human history: democracy, the rule of law, human rights, and so on. In that case, your motto would be, “It’s us vs. them, and that’s how I like it.” Unfortunately, this attitude fits our natural tendencies like a glove. That is one of the reasons it is so appealing: It feels right. Of course, a lot of things feel right but turn out to be a disaster. For everyone who is made uncomfortable, if not repelled, by that position, we must soldier on through our hypocrisy. We must do the work of figuring out how to live with each other despite the fact that we are emotional creatures that form attachments to some people and not others, not perfectly rational robots. The most important thing any individual can do in this situation is to simply acknowledge that when it comes to “our people” we are hopelessly biased. We should not try to rationalize our way out of this bias, or try to find an excuse why it is really true, or try to deny it completely. We should just accept it. Acceptance is a steady wind that can blow us towards tolerance and (more) equal treatment of people different from us. Just knowing that your hypocrisy exists will empower you to see the world differently – and more clearly. Awareness of our hypocrisy makes understanding other people’s motivations much easier. This makes the world a more understandable place, which is an obvious benefit to anyone living in it. As I said above, we all carry two sets of books, two sets of moral rules in our heads. One for Us, the other for Them. Keep those books within reach. That way you can refer to them whenever you are confronted with difficult decisions in a diverse, interconnected world. What does one moral code say that the other does not? How big of a difference is there? Can you reconcile the two? Anyone who is capable of compassion for people not like them struggles with this inborn hypocrisy. Thankfully, that is most people, even if, sometimes, we behave otherwise. ### Prejudice is inevitable, bigotry takes effort. Diversity is a big topic, and its existence in the society around you, or lack thereof, is something out of the control of the individual. But prejudice, a frequent side effect of it, is not. Whether we are dispensing it or receiving it, prejudice is something we all deal with everyday living in diverse societies. This section is about how we dispense prejudice, not how we receive it, and how you might change the way you think about your own prejudice for your and everyone else’s benefit. For a long time, prejudice against other groups of people for various reasons was not just accepted, but expected and encouraged. In the After Age, such behavior is no longer welcomed, at least publicly (usually). This is a considerable improvement, but we could certainly do better. To do so, we have to go a step farther and take an honest look at what we are doing when we discriminate against each other. As with diversity itself, refusing to acknowledge the nature of the problem makes it impossible to manage or overcome. Prejudice is a core human trait. To expect yourself or anyone else to rid themselves of prejudice is like expecting them to rid themselves of their sex drive. Prejudice, like sexual desire, exists in virtually everyone and can arise in us without us being consciously aware of it, even against our best intentions. To believe otherwise is to be like a zealous monk who whips himself every time a sexy thought pops into his head. This is why I find accusations of racism or sexism or any other expression of prejudice to be beside the point. I know for a fact that I am racist and sexist, and many other “-ists” as well. I also know that, in all likelihood, you are too. I suppose there are a very few lucky people who hold no biases against other people. People who have, somehow, miraculously, not absorbed the hundreds of different prejudices of society around them. People who judge others “not by the color of their skin, but by the content of their character”. Those rare individuals, if they exist, are few and far between. Most of us are damned with suspicious, judgmental minds. In other words, the capacity to discriminate is universal. But that does not take any of us off the hook. Prejudice, when it comes out of our heads and into the real world, harms other people. It harms the fabric of our societies, societies which are becoming more diverse every day, in a world that is more interdependent every day. Is it possible to remove prejudice from our minds? I strongly doubt it. Most of the thoughts, and virtually all of the feelings we have pop into our heads uninvited. They are, furthermore, frequently contradictory, inconsistent, unstable, and incoherent. So not only do we have very little control over our thoughts and feelings, but it is often impossible to tell what they mean, or how much we believe them, or what we believe, period. Given that mess, how would we root out something as ingrained as suspicion of differences in other people? So widespread and varied that it exists and has existed in every human culture in the world? Behavior so fundamental we can see it happening in chimpanzees and insects? People spend their entire lives in therapy trying to change a bad mental habit. Overcoming bias would require the same on a global basis. Meanwhile, we have an urgent problem on our hands: We are diverse, and becoming more so. How do we get along? There is an alternative, one that works on the same problem, but from the outside in. It is not as idealistic as doing the work to truly uproot our prejudice, but it is more practical and thus more achievable. It is not to change what we think, but how we act. This distinction between thoughts and actions is the difference between prejudice and bigotry. Most of the time, we are either ignorant of the prejudice we feel towards certain people, or are aware of it, and try to ignore it. Sometimes, however, we are aware of our prejudices, or are made aware of them, and then embrace them. This is bigotry. When it comes to living and getting along in the diverse, interconnected societies that are so common in the After Age, it is bigotry that is the real problem. The distinction between prejudice and bigotry is the most important distinction we can make when living with people that are different from us. As I have explained above, prejudice exists in our minds, and we cannot control what we feel or, mostly, what we think. What we can control is how we act. Bigotry, ultimately, is an act, because it is a conscious, deliberate decision. The difference between prejudice and bigotry is like the difference between being so angry at someone you want to punch them, and actually punching them, or the difference between being attracted to a beautiful stranger, and grabbing their ass. Just as we are capable of knowing the difference between violent feelings and violent actions, or between sexual attraction and sexual assault, we must learn to distinguish between prejudice and bigotry. Prejudice is inevitable; bigotry is wrong. Bigotry can be anything from being slightly colder to people of a certain group, to putting them in concentration camps. Both are conscious acts. In both cases, we allow our bias against certain people to overcome our obligation to treat them as we would want to be treated ourselves. I would like nothing better than if we all cared for everyone equally, with no regard for creed or color. And I encourage anyone to make a conscious effort in pursuit of the ideal solution of overcoming prejudice from within. I do not think it is possible to do so, but I could be wrong, and at the very least you might learn something about yourself. Good luck. In the meantime, I will settle for everyone keeping our nasty, or merely ignorant, impatient, angry, fearful, dismissive, or otherwise, opinions to ourselves, and maybe a few friends who know better than to take us seriously. As an individual, controlling how you act instead of what you think or feel is a much easier task to pull off. Focusing on how we act, rather than what we think or feel, may not do much for our own prejudice. However, it starves society around us of the bigotry that causes so much discord, and provides room for an alternative to grow and gain strength. This is not the perfect solution, but we do not need to be perfect to be great. ### Bigotry does not have to be incorrect or unjustified to be wrong. Bigotry may come from personal experience or national history, from paranoid delusions or the most rigorous scientific study. Bigotry is founded on prejudice, and it would be naive to claim that all prejudice is unjustified. Many people get tripped up on this. Those who have discovered, or think they’ve discovered, some truth or justification to their prejudice use that truth to justify bigotry. They focus on it, and everything else becomes irrelevant. They forget that the world is chock full of truths, and that some matter more than others. Ultimately, where bigotry comes from is not as important as its effects, especially when it comes to how you and I should behave in the world. Bigotry harms others and destroys the fabric of society. That fabric is what allows us to live lives infinitely more peaceful and prosperous than our ancestors, and opens the door to a future even more promising. That is why it is so destructive. As an individual, keeping this bigger picture in mind helps resolve conflicts between our opinions and life experience and the demands of others who do not share them. You do not have to find a solution to our collective disagreements. You just have to get along with other people, one day at a time, for the rest of your life. Simple. ### Bigotry is an individual sin, not a societal one. Everyone on Earth lives in a society with history, and anyone who knows anything about history knows it is filled with horrible things done by one group of people to another group of people. Murder, mayhem, and oppression pop up in every scene, at every location around the world, from the beginning. History has its baggage, and like an airport luggage carousel, more tumbles out every minute. Whether it happened hundreds of years ago, or just yesterday, history’s baggage has a direct effect on the way we live today and the way we treat each other. It is the source of most of the prejudice we have. That said, neither history nor society is to blame for our bigotry, yours and mine. Only we are, you and I. History may be a cause of our prejudice, but bigotry is a conscious act, and all of us have control (most of the time) over our actions. Because bigotry is an act, it is first and foremost an individual failing, not a societal one. Societies will always generate reasons for one group of people to discriminate against another. It is a flaw that is not going to go away, ever. It is up to us individuals to resist. If we treat bigotry as a symptom of some greater historical or social problem, we are giving others and ourselves permission to behave the same way as well, since we are products of the same flawed society, a society that is (mostly) beyond our control. But if we treat bigotry as a personal failure, then we are all empowered to do something about it. It is front and center in our lives. Furthermore, so much of bigotry is simply human behavior that has very little to do with the specifics of the prejudice itself. When someone screams racial epithets at the supermarket, or joins a terrorist group targeting members of another religion, it has more to do with what is going on with that person than with the specifics of their prejudice. To be clear: prejudice is absolutely a product of society. Hatred, hostility, and suspicion between groups, which is adopted by members of those groups, is the result of social and historical forces. But this is a book about how you can help us to be great, not how we ought to be great. As I said, society is (mostly) out of your control. Your own behavior is not. Lying. Stealing. Cheating. These are all things we know we are not supposed to do. Bigotry has never been on that list, because hatred of people not like us was accepted, if not encouraged, as being part of a group. This has to change, and it is, slowly. The best way you can contribute to this change is to see bigotry like any other bad behavior rather than something beyond your control. We don’t blame other people when we lie or steal. We shouldn’t blame our bigotry on anyone else, either. It is our own responsibility. As an individual, viewing bigotry as a personal failure makes it more manageable. Rather than being tied up in huge social forces beyond our control, it is centered on us, on our behavior in the moment, day to day, person to person, in our lives. And the judge of our behavior is no longer history, but ourselves. ### Judge the individual. I judge. I am a judgmental person. But I know I’m not alone. We all judge each other. It is not hard for judgment to veer into bigotry since it is often fueled by prejudice. The secret to reducing the amount of bigotry we bring into the world is, if and when you judge others, judge them as individuals. There is an obvious problem with this approach: It is pretty much impossible to pull off completely. Our prejudices are always there, affecting our judgement. The ones we know about, the ones we have no clue about. Still, as difficult as this principle is to pull off, it has a couple things to its advantage. One, it is universally true. Judge others as individuals. It’s hard to argue with and it’s hard to think of exceptions. I guess you could argue we shouldn’t judge people at all, but let’s be realistic: We are going to anyway. Besides, some people totally deserve it. Two, it is always available. We can at any moment, in any interaction, ask ourselves whether we are really judging another person on who they are, or who we expect them to be. You can’t always know the extent of your own bias, but you can always take a second look at the person standing in front of you. Still, it is hard. My lazy mind would prefer to come to conclusions quickly. Judging everyone as an individual means judging everyone, individually. That is tiresome. It is easier when we are in direct contact with people we see regularly, but the modern world exposes us to dozens or hundreds of strangers a day, both in person and via information technology like TV and social media. It is tiring to not group individuals based on stereotypes and prejudices when we are made aware of so many other people on a daily basis. Focus on the people around you first. This is advice for individuals, not for governments or organizations. A government does not have the flexibility to treat each citizen as an individual. It must deal with us in bulk, and judge us in bulk. Its decisions and obligations are not the same as us individuals. Treating others as individuals, which is how we ourselves would prefer to be treated, is the best way to live with people who are different from you. It should come as no surprise then that the best way takes more effort. Nothing worth doing ever came easy. ### Diversity is our destiny. Human diversity, which flourished over the tens of thousands of years we spread across the globe, is emerging as our Achilles Heel as we reconnect in the After Age. It is not a problem limited to certain neighborhoods, or certain cities, or even certain countries. As the economies, cultures, and populations of the planet become more interconnected, the world itself starts to resemble one large, crowded, extremely diverse society. What happens inside an individual person, neighborhood, city, or nation struggling with diversity is a mirror and a prelude to what is happening to the world at large. In other words, there is no escape from this challenge but to face it head on. Diversity imposes a burden which takes effort to manage. As an individual, you can do your part by acknowledging the burden of diversity, while committing yourself to living with it. Keep in mind that our diversity, whatever its challenges, is a side-effect of other, wonderful things that have made your life infinitely better than your ancestors. There are few things in life worth doing that don’t take effort. The work we put into learning to live with each other will pay magnificent dividends, and already has. A society where people of different backgrounds, beliefs, practices, and cultures coexist comfortably, are treated equally, and mutually tolerated, must be considered our greatest achievement. It is proof that we can master the fear, mistrust, and anger that has caused so much grief and destruction in human history, and hobbles our progress today. A civilization that can pull that off can pull off anything. Whether such a civilization is possible is yet to be seen. Certainly, perfect harmony is not, but perfection is not required to achieve greatness. ## Your Government The primary purpose of government before the After Age, if it had any, was as a tool for the powerful to exploit the powerless. That was not its only purpose, but it was the primary one. In the After Age, government’s purpose is to serve the people. That is what is *expected*, it certainly does not do so all the time. But exploitation, when it happens, and certainly it does, is seen as a failure. We’ve raised our expectations. We demand better. This is a profound change. The fact that it is not universal (like so much progress) does not take away from its importance. Some governments serve their people better than others. A few governments still see their people as mere profit centers to be milked for cash. An even smaller few have a hostile relationship with their people and are obsessed with controlling and containing them. Most governments have a mix of these intentions. But even outside the democratic world, government as a service is the de facto expectation. A government that does a poor job of serving its people is a fragile government indeed. It is a dinosaur left over from the past, and we all know what happened to the dinosaurs. As the After Age spreads and matures, the transition of governments from exploiters to service providers will continue. But we continue to cling to the old model. And not just governments and their leaders – for sentimental reasons, we the people also have trouble letting go, as I will explain. As an individual, you can sharpen your understanding of government, how it works and how it does not work, by keeping this transformation in mind. Doing so will help you figure out what it is you really want from your government and protect you from political scams, conmen, false hopes, and empty promises. Your improved savvy benefits you, and all of us. To start, it helps to remember one simple rule: ### Government should serve a purpose, not an ideal. The greatest mistake we can make in governing is to believe that we are serving a higher purpose. Government is not sacred. Government is, or ought to be, simply a service that administers justice, collects the garbage, and many other things in between. In other words, government should serve a purpose, not an ideal. The belief that government is sacred is a holdover from our past. It was one of the ways exploitative rulers of the past (and present) justified their existence. The idea is a direct descendant of the ancient belief that the man or woman at the top of the social pyramid was a god. Gradually, that idea was watered down as it became harder and harder to convince anyone it was literally true. But it lingers, even in democracies that have thrown off the divine right of kings. To be fair to kings and queens, we the people have invested a lot in the idea as well. In fact, it is very hard for us to let it go. When we try, by overthrowing corrupt, controlling regimes, all too often we find ourselves crawling back to the old ways, like a lover in an abusive relationship. We like having leaders with symbolic power. We like believing that our rulers are divine, or at least very special and all-powerful. It is a comfort to us to think the people in charge were destined to be there, and that their leadership will protect us and bring our lives meaning. It is very hard for us, individually and communally, to view government as just a service and our leaders as, essentially, customer support. When we view government as a sacred institution whose every action is either an affirmation or betrayal of some higher spirit or ideal, we invite trouble. This has been proven over and over again in history, especially in the last 250 years. If you want ideals, in other words, if you are looking for *meaning*, find some ideals you believe in, and try living by them. Do not go looking for them in the government. And, if you do look for them in government, when you don’t find them, don’t try to impose them on it. Government is a huge, complicated bureaucracy that has enough trouble functioning well as it is without having to embody our fantasies of the ideal world. Treating government as something that serves a purpose rather than an ideal is, to be fair, somewhat of a luxury. In the past, it was hard to be so pragmatic. The living conditions of most people were desperate and their governments at best didn’t care, and often deliberately made things worse. Drastic, revolutionary, idealistic solutions like Communism, fascism, and theocracy were attractive (and still are) for their promise of radical change from the horrible status quo. They also were (and still are) easier to get passionate about than a more sensible course of action. The mass murder, oppression, and failed economies of Communist, fascist, and theocratic governments are the best argument for why trying to govern according to ideals is such a bad idea. But if you live in the After Age you don’t have the excuse of desperate circumstances to justify supporting radical ideology. Your life is far, far more comfortable than that of the French, Russian, or Chinese peasants who staged bloody revolutions and installed insane, radical regimes over the last 250 years. You have more than enough to eat, you live in comfortable surroundings, and your government does not systematically persecute its citizens. You can afford to be sensible. Even if you do feel persecuted by your government, because of your political opinions, or ethnicity or gender, or the religion you practice, or your economic class, your circumstances still do not match the dire circumstances of the past, and still do not justify those kinds of drastic measures. Our anger over injustice can spur us to action, but it can also blind us, make us too impatient, and knock out our reason. I am well aware that modern liberal democracy is, at least in part, the product of wild-eyed idealists dreaming up new ways of organizing government with no idea if it will work or not. Of course ideals matter. They are the invisible stuff that keeps these huge, imaginary social organizations – governments – glued together and existing in the real world. Government will never be reducible to mere purpose. But the future of government lies in being more purpose, or service driven, and much, much, much less ideal-driven. Ideals are vague, contradictory, and inflammatory dreams that can very easily lead us astray. But a purpose – to feed the hungry, pave the roads, clean the air – you either do it or you don’t. As an individual, you can help yourself understand the world around you better, and help your country be not just OK but great, by thinking of your government as more of a service, and less something that brings meaning to your life. ### To be passionate about politics is to make politics worse for everyone. In the After Age, most political battles happen at the margins about relatively unimportant things. I am not going to provide examples of “relatively unimportant things,” because I do not want to turn off anyone who thinks what I consider relatively unimportant to be absolutely important. However, I’m sure we can all come up with examples of controversies that are very important to us, but that if they were to be decided one way or another would not have a big effect on our lives as a whole. One way to find an example is to think of some political controversy that did not go your way, and ask yourself whether it was really the disaster you thought it would be at the time. And remember: by disaster I mean a real disaster, not a relative one. If your government maintains basic law and order, a justice and legal system, a public health system, a public education system, national defense, and a social safety net, then the important arguments have already been settled – in your favor. It might not seem that way when we are arguing over exactly how these things should work, what they should cost, or how much they should do, but that is to lose the forest for the trees. For most of human history, no government provided all of these things, and few provided any of them. For people who do not live in the After Age, these services may still be missing. Compared to that huge leap, our political controversies look very petty. Unfortunately, all too often these petty controversies capture government, forcing it to serve an ideal (one side or the other side of a controversy) rather than serve a purpose. And then government starts to fail at all of the critical and uncontroversial things it needs to be doing. To be passionate about politics is to make politics worse for everyone. Government is an administrative function. It ought to be boring, at least to anyone outside the process looking to be entertained (for those inside government trying to solve problems it is, hopefully, exciting). As individuals in the After Age, we can help make our governments better by governing ourselves better. Stop watching the show, stop responding to the provocations of professional attention-seekers who are looking for people to applaud them. Start supporting leaders who represent the best in you: your ability to cooperate with other people. (These people tend to be bland, uninspiring compromisers. That is what politics does to people who actually practice it. Be grateful to them for the sacrifice they have made.) Our “ideal” government will reveal itself through the work we put into making government work properly and well. If you are an American, I do not need to tell you that draining the passion from your politics can have a very positive personal benefit as well. We have lived through one divisive, nerve-wracking election after another for the last 20 years. It sucks. It is a tax on our mental health. You might think that it is the politicians that start these fires, and to a certain extent that is true. But the nature of politicians is to pick up on the vibes we are sending them. If we show them we are unamused by their antics, they will get the message eventually. ### Government is oppressive by nature. Government is a conservative institution dedicated to controlling human behavior, and that is how it behaves. Expecting government to be anything different is, at a minimum, frustrating. Government should be expected to be heavy-handed, reactionary, conservative (wherever it may lie on the left/right spectrum), tone-deaf, insensitive, un-experimental, non-evolutionary, clumsy, uninspiring, and slow. Government will almost always lag behind society’s most progressive or visionary opinions, insights, culture, and practices. It is not that we shouldn’t hope that sometimes government will surprise us by leading, rather than following. It is that when it does not, we should not despair. That is what government is. To expect anything else would be like driving a car into the sea in hopes it will turn into a boat. And then feeling deeply betrayed when it does not. Because government is a conservative institution dedicated to controlling human behavior, we individuals need to understand and accept that it will be a little oppressive – i.e., a little “controlling” – most of the time. We can see this behavior in anyone who has power over us: the police, our boss, our mom. They become – we become – slightly oppressive when given responsibility over other people. We come to believe that we must be that way, and those we oppress come to resent us for it. Acceptance of this unfortunate truth does not mean acceptance of oppression beyond “slightly”. A distant, tone-deaf, or clumsy bureaucracy is slightly oppressive. Imprisonment and execution without trial is deeply oppressive. Somewhere between we draw the line. The arc and promise of the After Age is to render that line unnecessary by making the drastic circumstances that force drastic acts a thing of the past. As the conditions of human life improve, we have less to fear from our government because it has less to fear from us. ### Democracy is (just) one more perk of the After Age. Being a democracy is not a requirement for a country to enter the After Age. It just seems to work out that way. The reason is that as people get wealthier, better educated, freer and more empowered in other aspects of their lives, enjoying the freedom to choose their leaders, rather than fear them, seems a natural next step. But democracy is just a method, not an inevitability, and it is not immune to the fundamental rule for government in the After Age: Government should serve a purpose, not an ideal. It is not hard to imagine a form of government that works better than democracy, especially since we are witness to the failures of democracy, and the successes of non-democracies, all the time. Many countries are trying to create exactly such a form of government. Or at least they claim they are. We shall see. More likely, their rulers are simply trying to justify remaining in power. In practice, it is definitely true that less democratic countries sometimes serve their people better than more democratic ones. Democratic politics often stand in the way of getting things done or doing what is right. In this case, it might be better to think of democratic standards – political representation, freedom of expression, the rule of law, and so on – as standards of governmental quality and safety, like building codes. To meet all the building codes in constructing a house is more expensive and time-consuming. You can get what you need by ignoring them completely, and you can build the house faster and cheaper. But the end result of a house built to code is more pleasant to live in, higher quality, and, most important, less likely to collapse on top of you. Of course, some people can’t afford the nicer, safer, democratic house. Yet. But the greatness of the After Age is that eventually we all will. That said, thinking of government as a service rather than an ideal ought to put pressure on democracies as well. For example, by encouraging them to spend less time exercising democracy, and more time focusing on results – services – for their people. That would be an improvement. Government should serve a purpose, not an ideal. If democracy is preventing government from serving the people, then having less of it might be an improvement. The After Age is full of wonderful advances that our ancestors never would have thought possible. Government that is regularly chosen by the people and serves the people well is one of them. That it is not always well-executed in reality does not diminish its value. For you, the individual, what this means is this: Don’t give up on democracy, whether you live in one or not. You deserve to have all the material benefits of the After Age – greater wealth, health, and so on – and the political freedoms of democracy, too. You are totally worth it. ## Your Money The After Age has brought an astoundingly high standard of living to billions of people around the world. This improvement happened over generations, and the greatest advances occurred, in many places, before most people alive today were born. In other words, most people living in the After Age do not know what it was like to live before it. All evidence suggests it was, at the very least, a hassle, and often miserable. The average per-capita income has gone up 1500% - 2000% over the last 200 years. This is in absolute terms. In other words, if you were living in 1820 and were as rich as the average inhabitant of the After Age today, you would be 20 times richer back then. However, this statistic does not really do justice to the amazing improvements in living standards. For example, even if you were the richest person alive in 1820, you still might die from a disease that is easily treated today. You still had to read by candle light. You still had to travel by carriage to most places. And so on. How much more valuable is a light bulb than a candle? Ten times? A hundred times? Economists attempt to measure these improvements, but it is difficult to know exactly. Suffice to say, things have gotten better. By a lot. The number one reason for all of the prosperity we have now is what we call capitalism. Despite its obvious success in helping billions of people escape poverty, we have mixed feelings about capitalism, and we should. There is a long list of capitalism’s crimes, and they’re all true. Capitalism is exploitative. It rewards greed and selfish behavior. It feeds on the destruction of the natural world. It undermines community, morality, and existing ways of life. It takes away individual purpose and identity. You get what you pay for, or rather, you pay for what you get. We have gotten quite a lot from capitalism, and we have paid dearly, with our entire way of life, and our entire sense of self. That said, every attack on capitalism is like striking a mirror. Capitalism is a word we use to describe human behavior, exercised freely, in the realm of economics and money. Exploitation, greed, environmental destruction, immorality – all of these things have existed without capitalism. The only way we could remove these from capitalism would be by removing them from human nature. Replace capitalism with some other method of economic organization and these flaws will show up in another form. We can escape from capitalism’s flaws, but only if we can master ourselves first. In the meantime, we must keep making money. We’ve got nearly eight billion mouths to feed, and counting. Capitalism is a critical part of bringing those of us not yet in the After Age into the After Age because it converts self interest into greater prosperity for everyone. Since capitalism works best when everyone participates, turning our backs on capitalism now is not merely foolish but cruel to those using it to build a better life for themselves and future generations. This is true even if it can sometimes seem that capitalism is the cruel one. Capitalism is not noble. Greed is not good. Human beings are noble and good and also greedy, selfish, and crass. It takes a certain maturity, resolve, and willpower to both recognize the inequities and cruelties of capitalism, and yet tolerate it as a whole for the greater good it brings to humanity. It is a test of our ability to hold two conflicting ideas in our minds at the same time, and still retain our good judgment. Which, as should be clear by now, is one of the fundamental demands of the After Age. As individuals, by allowing ourselves to see the dual nature of capitalism we are better equipped to make the right choice when it comes to the countless economic decisions we make in our lives. I am not talking about what sort of economic policy to support, but how we want to behave when it comes to running a business, working for or employing others, buying, selling, or making money in any way. ### It’s about money, not fairness. The wealth gap between the richest and poorest human beings is wider today than it has ever been in the history of the world. Much, much wider. We live in an age when a single person might spend as much money in a day as tens of thousands of others do in their entire lives. An age when one child might be chauffeured around the world in a private jumbo jet, while other children starve to death for want of a crust of bread. Today, inequality is so severe that ten of the world’s richest people have more wealth than 50% of the rest. This is an extremely unfair state of affairs. But here’s the thing: The After Age isn’t about those ten people. It’s about all of us. Remember, the goal in reach is to bring the prosperity of the After Age to all of humanity. Given this, the fact that some people have much more than others is irrelevant, provided that fact does not prevent the goal from being achieved. As with so much in this book, I am not asking you to change your behavior, only to reconsider how you see the world. Changing our focus from what the wealthy have to what the rest of us lack does not necessarily change any of our goals, or the methods used to achieve them. Do we need better health care, infrastructure, public security, or a cleaner environment? If we cannot afford them, a good place to look for the cash would be in the bank accounts of the wealthy. Inequality is at the heart of capitalism. So are lies, manipulation, and exploitation. When you buy something, you pay what you are willing to pay, not what is “fair”. When you work for someone else, your salary is what they offer and you accept, not what is “fair”. Capitalism is whatever we can get away with to make a buck. Anything else you could say about capitalism – good or bad – is just a side-effect. If you don’t like this state of affairs the best revenge is not to rage against the machine, but to use capitalism the way it uses us. Capitalism can help make us all rich. Then, maybe, we can say goodbye to capitalism, if we want. But by that point, we may not care. ### Opposition to free trade is wrong. In the United States, and elsewhere, opposition to free trade or “globalization” is often the only thing that both the left and the right agree on. Both oppose free trade because it hurts local workers by forcing down wages and moving jobs overseas where wages are lower. The left also dislikes that free trade waters down worker’s rights, unions, and environmental standards. The right dislikes that free trade allows foreign nations to “get rich off us” by using cheap exports to rich countries to pull themselves up economically and catch up in wealth and status. Workers, whatever their politics, are scared of losing their jobs. I do not disagree with any of that. Low-cost foreign competition for work hurts workers in wealthier countries like the United States. I personally feel this competition in my own career. But there is a much bigger moral issue here we all must consider. It is easily ignored, perhaps because it is hiding in plain sight. The reason the jobs go overseas is because wages are lower there. The reason wages are lower there is because people are poorer. Not just poorer, but poor, period. They have no money. The hardships of the unemployed in the US or France or Japan are, on average, mild compared to those of the unemployed in rural China, India, or Nicaragua. This is also true with respect to immigrants, legal or otherwise, who offer their work for lower wages and with fewer demands than native-born workers. Generally speaking, the reason someone is willing to work for less is because they need the money more. For them, the alternative may be a life of dire poverty. You may recall from the introduction why I have written this book. It is not for your benefit, dear citizen of the After Age, though I hope you do benefit from it. It is for everyone else who does not live in the After Age yet. When we try (or succeed) in pulling up the drawbridge and keeping factories and jobs at home, or low-wage immigrants out, we may think we are doing the right thing. And we are helping some people – our people. But the people who could most use help, objectively speaking, are being screwed. If pulling a billion people out of poverty in China means layoffs in America, the richest country in the world, so be it. I’ll never get elected president saying that. But there are a lot of obviously true things that presidents never say. None of the common criticisms of free trade are incorrect. I am well aware that the ideal of free trade can and is weaponized by greed to harm people on both sides of the bargain. I am also aware that trade is not the only way to get rich, and that nations exploit free trade for unfair advantage. Nor am I arguing for open borders or more immigration. In fact, I am not advocating any specific policy one way or the other. I am simply pointing out the moral contradiction here. As with so much in the After Age, we must find a way to balance this contradiction in our own heads when we think about the world around us. Free trade and free markets, broadly speaking, were critical to achieving the weath, health and freedom we enjoy in the After Age. If today they hurt people that once benefited from them, we should find some solution to help that does not hurt others who are worse off. To deny them their chance to get rich, now that we’ve gotten ours, is obscenely selfish, and wrong. If you can think of the lives of people not like you as valuable, then the benefits of free trade can fill you with pride and joy. People’s lives all over the world are steadily improving. The net amount of human prosperity is increasing. This is a profoundly good thing that dwarfs in importance our petty resentments over borders and trade. If you have just lost your job to someone on the other side of the world, I do not expect you to agree with this, or want to hear it at all. But it is still true. ### Good enough is glorious. Inequality is hard to stomach. Wide gaps between what some have and others don’t does not feel right to many people, especially when some struggle with the basic necessities of life. This feeling is only made worse when those with so much wealth manipulate government and society to get more. But there are other reasons for our unhappiness with inequality. No matter how much we have, someone else will have more. We compare ourselves to them and feel bad about ourselves. We feel anxiety that we are not keeping up with them, so we work harder, sacrificing the finite moments of our life to something we dislike. We feel that we are somehow lesser than those with more money, and that inferiority seeps into our relationships with others, and with ourselves. We feel jealousy that we don’t have what they do, and we get angry, bitter, and resentful. Or if it is not other people’s wealth and status that bothers us, it is some perceived material lack in our own lives. We become obsessed with possessing a bigger house, better car, or some other thing we want. We know having it will improve our lives, but we lose track of the fact that the improvement it brings is likely to be small and superficial. Capitalism did not create these feelings, but it certainly feeds off of them. Whether you blame this situation on capitalism, or human nature (to me there’s not much difference) it is clear that capitalism makes it worse. But capitalism can also make those feelings better. Anyone who lives in the After Age is richer than 99% of all the human beings who have ever lived. If you live in the After Age, it gets easier and easier to say “I have everything I need, and most of what I want, and I just don’t care anymore.” Where that line is drawn is not something that can be dictated from on high. Governments can try, but ultimately being satisfied with your life is something you must achieve on your own. You can achieve it by working to get it (or demanding it as a right). But you can also achieve it by accepting what you have as good enough. That acceptance is different for everyone. One of the great things about capitalism, for all its flaws, is it makes it easier for everyone to draw that line, eventually. But it will never draw it for you. ## Our Nations Our nations are in trouble. They’re really having a hard time these days, and they need our help. You see, once upon a time the nation state was the biggest, baddest, most important unit of humanity there was. The nation was everything: language, culture, religion, history, government, law, economy, military might, and territorial integrity. That is all over now. Advances in technology and trade in the After Age have dragged nations into a forced intimacy with each other against their will. If once nations were lone cowboys riding the range, independent and free, today they are commuters packed into a subway car, gritting their teeth as they stumble into each other with each twist and turn of the track. Socially, economically, culturally, technologically, and environmentally, nations are now utterly intertwined and dependent on each other. Like players in a never-ending game of Twister, their every move is limited and compromised by the interlocking relationships between all of them. This does not mean nations are irrelevant. Nation states are and will be the building blocks of global peace and prosperity in the After Age. Not to mention our beloved homes. But they are now part of a network of relationships between them that has eclipsed any individual nation in power and influence. It is to this network that every nation and its leadership must ultimately pay homage, whether they want to or not. Yet most nations – and their people – would prefer to behave as if this were not true. They would prefer the illusion that they stand alone, free to behave however they want. This is understandable. It is, after all, a difficult thing to accept, that we are tied to others, stuck in a web of relationships we did not choose, and from which there is no escape. It is a difficult thing to accept for an individual person, but for an entire country it is an even bigger pill to swallow. How could a sovereign nation, with its own government, military, language, culture, and glorious history, not be master of its own destiny? Yet none is. This reality is both humbling and a little humiliating. As long as nations resist this fact, they are likely to be incompetent in their dealings with each other. They will view other countries as the perpetual bearers of bad news, the reminders of their oppression, and the nagging complicators of their desires. They will resent each other, and like people that resent each other and yet are forced to live together, they will find ways to make life more difficult for each other for no good reason – out of spite. But if nations can accept this new reality, then they, and we, have much to gain. This forced intimacy is a herald of a more peaceful and prosperous future for every country and the people in them. That is because this network between nations is actually a power grid, a source of strength. It is also a thousand times better than what it replaced, which was a violent indifference to the fate of other nations and their people. Since nations are big, dumb social constructions, not beings capable of accepting anything, what I really mean is that we the people that make up nations must understand and accept this new reality. We must change the way we think about our own country, other countries, and the people in them. By changing the way you view foreign countries and foreign peoples, you will be better prepared to live and succeed in a world where the definition of “foreign” is transforming under pressure. At the same time, the combined power of all of our opinions can redefine nations from within and push them along a better path towards greater, and happier, cooperation. ### There are no more barbarians. Barbarians were the people out there, beyond the pale, beyond the borders of civilization. The people whose ways and lives were utterly alien to ours. To us they were more “primitive” and less civilized (and more free, perhaps). Yet despite their primitive ways, or because of them, they were a threat. They proved they were a threat by invading every so often and tearing up our soft, fragile societies. Today, there are no more barbarians. The people of the world share one economic, social, cultural, and technological order. There are no societies that exist outside this order. Everyone has been brought in, willing or otherwise. Where did the barbarians go? They did not go extinct, or ride off into the sunset. They were tamed, and became us. True, there are hundreds of different versions of this shared order, from Indonesia to Ireland to Uruguay, but, on balance, the similarities overwhelm the differences. Most humans live in or near cities. We participate in the global economy and its culture. We have similar dress, hairstyles, homes, transportation, tools, and so on. We have similar ways of organizing our governments, businesses, and families. We have the same technology, the same knowledge, the same information. We have the same diseases. With each passing year, we share more and more. But it’s not just that we share the same fashion, phones, or fast food. There are many more small, intangible things we do that are increasingly similar around the world, in every nation. What we do first when we wake up in the morning, or last when we go to bed at night. What we think about when we think about our parents or children or friends or lovers. What we expect from our government or family or employers or strangers. How we behave and expect others to behave in traffic, at the store, at work, at school. How we do the dishes, brush our teeth, go shopping, watch TV, fix ourselves a snack, surf the web, have sex, are born, and die. For a thousand habits and patterns of life, we are converging. These similarities are not things often remarked upon in the news. They have no apparent effect on political decisions, international trade, or military engagements. No one (or very few people) are paying attention to them, because they are so mundane. But they are increasingly in alignment. We are increasingly in alignment. There are no more barbarians. I do not want to ignore the big differences between lives in the 21st century, despite all we share. Life in, for example, the Central African Republic is very different from life in Switzerland. But those two countries, and any other, are still part of the same civilization. None of them present an alternative to what is, and is becoming, the default mode of existence. The disappearance of the barbarians means that to the extent there is one world order, there is no outside threat to it. In other words, today our greatest and only enemy is internal, not external. Since, in the course of human history, so many civilizations fell to the external disorder that surrounded them, meaning barbarians, this suggests that the After Age has a decent chance of lasting a very, very long time. If we don’t blow it. One way we could blow it is to continue to treat foreign countries and foreign peoples as if they were barbarians. They are not, and neither are we. They may be a threat, a competitor, or an adversary. But if they are, they are from within, not without. This is a subtle difference, but it is a profound one, especially if we allow it to take root in our minds and influence how we see the rest of the world around us. Could someone who enjoys the same TV shows as you support bombing your house? Yes, of course – absolutely. But the increasing number of things we share make the imbalance on either side of a border less extreme, and thus less unstable and less likely to tip into violence. And they also make the reasons behind tensions and hostility between nations more understandable. Our fears, desires, and motivations become easier to understand as our lives become more similar. This new understanding is least likely to come from the top down (although it is there, too). Governments and their leadership are programmed to see other nations as external threats. It is more likely to come from our individual realizations that the patterns of daily living that make up our lives are increasingly shared by billions of people around the planet. As an individual, recognition of these similarities can make the world beyond the borders of your homeland seem less mysterious, and thus less threatening. Besides contributing to a healthier collective attitude towards foreign nations, and their people, being less fearful of what is foreign can empower you, too. Go ahead, make the world your oyster. ### Include your morality in your patriotism. Adolf Hitler once said “what is right is what is good for the German people.” It is disturbing to realize that, when it comes to our own people, most of us tend to agree with Hitler. Loyalty to our nation, or a certain people within it, is baked into our societies. As I have already said, despicable acts when committed by “one of us” against “one of them” are often accepted, even celebrated, yet the same acts committed by them against us are cause for righteous anger. Of course, this double standard is not true for everyone all the time. And of course we can have compassion and sympathy for people of other nations. So perhaps comparing us to Hitler is a bit extreme. But if I am being extreme it is only because I want to shock you out of your complacency. The statement is only extreme because I added Hitler’s name to it, not because its message is really that different from how, when push comes to shove, we treat other nations and their people. Sooner or later loyalty to our nation comes into direct conflict with an obvious moral law, one even a child could point out. It is at that point that many, many people, people who would take offense at being lumped together with Hitler, end up coming to the same conclusion as the most evil person in history: That what is right is what is good for us and what is wrong is what is bad for us. Period. National governments are and will be the last to recognize this hypocrisy. This is not just because it is taboo for any national politician to express sympathy towards another nation’s needs or wants. National governments are created to serve one nation state, not humanity as a whole. It is simply what they do. To expect governments to care about the fate of anything else would be like expecting a corporation to donate all of its profits to charity. Instead, it is up to us as individual citizens to change our own thinking: Any sort of morality that ends at the border is no morality at all. Accepting this difficult truth does not mean ignoring the practical realities of life among 195 nations and almost 8 billion people. It does not mean abandoning national borders, or national self-interest, or national identity. It is about accepting this truth into your personal moral calculations. It is about allowing yourself to recognize when your national interests are in conflict with your own moral laws. I am not dictating what those moral laws are (OK, maybe a little, but that’s not my primary point here). The point is, whatever they are, too often we ignore them when it comes to how we treat foreign nations and peoples. As I have said already, recognizing our bias, in this case, our national bias, allows us to more clearly see the motivations of others, which makes the world a more understandable, and less threatening place. This can only be a good thing, both individually, and for everyone. National (or ethnic, or religious) bias is our default setting. It is as old as the hills. But that does not mean it cannot change. Cannibalism, human sacrifice, slavery, and genocide were all at one point accepted behavior. Today they are universally reviled. Someday this ugly gap between what is OK for “us” and what is OK for “them” will meet the same fate. The road there begins in your head. ### Your side is capable of everything the other side did. Genocide, enslavement, wars of aggression, duplicity and double-dealing: these are flaws in humanity, not one particular tribe. Such knowledge does not acquit us of our crimes, or those who sinned against us. But remembering we are all capable of them might put a brake on whatever righteous anger we feel towards innocent descendants of past aggressors. Of course, maybe they are not so innocent. But neither are we. Stop thinking of the horrible things done in history as a crime by this or that people or country. Instead, think of them as one more example of how we – meaning the human race – behaves horribly. Now it is our responsibility to ensure they do not happen again. Or at least, less often. What you and I can do as individuals to help is recognize this potential in ourselves. Yes, you are capable of participating in genocide, of owning slaves, of cheering the deaths of innocent people – or at the very least, standing by while these things happen. Now that you’ve admitted you could do it, perhaps you will be more watchful in the future. By the way, there is a positive flip side to this. If we must take ownership of the worst in human history, we can also take ownership of the best. Humanity’s greatest achievements are *our* greatest achievements. Those achievements could be one small step for a man, like the moon landing, or giant leaps for humankind, like the printed word, the discovery of electricity, or nonviolent social change. Sure, they happened first in one place and time. But that is mere chance. Whoever you are, and wherever you live, you can and should proudly claim these achievements as part of your heritage. You can draw strength and hope from them that the future can be better than the past. ### The stability of all nations is in the interest of every nation. Undermining the government or society of other countries is both wrong and foolish. It is like starting a fire in your neighbor’s house in hopes of getting them to move, and then being surprised when your own house goes up in flames. Instability and chaos spread quickly and unpredictably in a crowded world. Pyromania in such circumstances is a suicidal habit. Are there circumstances that justify meddling in other countries? I cannot think of any. History, which for national governments should be considered valuable, hard-won experience, strongly advises against foreign meddling. From the Austro-Hungarians allowing Lenin safe passage to Russia to the American-led overthrow of Saddam Hussein, placing your hand on the scale rarely seems to turn out well. One of the lessons of the last 200 years, if not far longer, is that destroying the stability, integrity, or internal order of a nation – no matter how despicable we may believe its government to be – is always a mistake. National governments are complex systems, and when they die, the consequences are unpredictable. If you overthrow a national government to save its people or reduce some hypothetical threat to your own, don’t be surprised if you end up causing far more misery than if you had done nothing. The best people to decide a nation’s fate are the people of that nation. Not only will they be the most effective, but the change they make will be the most enduring. Or to put it another way, you can tell an alcoholic they are ruining their life, you can send them to rehab or prison, threaten, beg, and plead with them, but in the end, they will only sober up for good when they decide they have had enough. It is my firm belief, and history backs me up, that given time, nations, like people, transform themselves. As an individual, be wary of any plans to solve another nation’s problems for them, or any attempts to blame your own country’s problems on another nation. These two approaches work about as well for nations as they do for individual people. ### Karma is real in international relations. It is unfortunately true that individuals can get away with bad behavior over and over again and never pay for it. The world is a big place and it is easy to disappear and start over somewhere else. The same is not true for nation states. The community of nations is less than 200 strong. When one nation treats another in a way that it would not want to be treated itself, there are always consequences, eventually. When it comes to international relations, nations that behave like con men, liars, cheats, bullies, or backstabbers cannot just slip out of town and move on. There’s nowhere else to go. National deeds reverberate in history, and in the minds of those you harmed. Remember that the next time your country’s army marches triumphantly through your defeated enemy’s capital. What goes around, comes around. ## Our World These are pretty hectic times. Actually, every time is hectic. But today the cacophony is audible everywhere, and nonstop – there is no escaping it. We hear about all the crazy things happening in our world and it feels like things are falling apart. “The more complicated the world becomes, the more ways things could go wrong.” That seems to be the storm cloud we live under today. I guess it is true, in a simplistic sort of way. If we are talking about the fate of the world however, then “complicated” and “wrong” should be more clearly defined. Does wrong mean catastrophically wrong? Or is it more like, when you have more things, there’s more things that can break, but on the other hand, each individual thing is less important? In other words, it’s unclear if it matters that the more complicated the world is, the more ways things could go wrong. In a complicated world many, many things are going on all at once. In that case, the amount of things going wrong is massively outnumbered by all the things going right – or things just going. Our bodies are made of trillions of cells, themselves driven by millions of chemical reactions happening every second. None of these cells is following a script. They’re not under anyone’s control. They are simply doing their thing, responding to stimuli and opportunities both internal and external. But by doing their thing, they are inadvertently contributing to a process going on that is vastly bigger than them. I don’t think it is a stretch to compare the chaos that runs our bodies to the chaos that moves the world. The world is out of our control. This was always true, but now we know it, and are reminded of it daily. But try not to let it frighten you. Instead, embrace it. It is not as bad as you think. In fact, it’s OK. Maybe even great. ## Our Future Back in the 20th century, some psychologists came up with a little experiment. Two volunteers would play a card game where they could either cooperate with their opponent and split a pot of money, or betray them and get the whole thing. But if they both double-crossed each other, both got nothing. Played once or twice, the results of the game were predictable: Both players betrayed the other, and both got nothing. But when the players were told there was no limit on the number of rounds, and to just keep playing, their behavior changed. Eventually, most players fell into a routine of cooperation, making the same cooperative move every time, and sharing the reward every time. Round after round, until the experiment ended (or the psychologists ran out of money). Humanity is stuck playing a version of this game. We have been playing one round after another since the beginning of history. We play it as individuals, we play it as groups, we play it as nations. It is fundamentally the same game at every level. When played rationally, the game is pretty boring. But the temptation is always there to play the game to win big. Out of fear, or greed, or for power, or just because we can. To take it all for ourselves, our family, our tribe, our nation, our religion, our party. For most of human history, this strategy may have made some sense. There was so little knowledge of what the world was like, and not enough reason to believe you would be around tomorrow to make cooperation worth it. But that isn’t true anymore. There is no “final” round in this game. It goes as long as we want. Which means the rewards are potentially limitless. It also means playing to win big is all the more senseless. Human history is a story of increasing cooperation. I believe that story continues. Not because I believe in the inherent goodness of humanity (I believe in the inherent humanity of humanity). But because, luckily, our circumstances force us in that direction, in the same way the volunteers in the game eventually figure out that the best way to play the game is to split the pot, round after round. It is cooperating with each other, not competing against each other (or merely being indifferent), that has brought all of us the best things in life. Not everything, but the best things. The things so great you don’t even notice them. Like not having our survival depend on whether the harvest will be good. Or not getting murdered by bands of thieves in our sleep. Or civilization itself. (It is cooperation that will dig us out of the climate change mess we find ourselves in. I do not think it is an oversimplification to say that the biggest obstacle to solving the problem of global warming is a lack of cooperation. All of the other ingredients – the technology, the knowledge, the money – are in place. We only lack cooperation.) Don’t get me wrong: competition is great, too. But competition is meaningless without cooperation. Our ability to cooperate channels competition the way a furnace contains a fire: it gives it purpose by turning its random energy into meaningful outcomes. Even where competition is most beneficial, in the free market, it is riding a symphony of cooperation. We see businesses at war in the market and see only the two competitors, forgetting all the people on each side cooperating intensely. It is true that competition is more attractive, sexier, and sometimes more individually rewarding than cooperation. It is also more fun, sometimes. But only in the way a shooting star is more noteworthy than the sun. One zooms across the sky for a moment, drawing a gasp of appreciation. The other shines steadily for billions of years, fueling all life on Earth. It is time for us to grow up and accept the responsibilities we have to conduct life on Earth in a serious manner. Cooperation is how we have achieved greatness as a species. More cooperation is how we will achieve even more greatness in the future. # Part: Conclusion ## It’s Not All About You In conclusion, it’s not all about you. It’s not all about your wants, needs, opinions, rights, freedoms, beliefs, personal fulfillment, people, country, religion, politics, money, or favorite sports team. Don’t get me wrong: It *is* about you. It is absolutely about you. That is the whole point of the After Age: You matter. It’s just not *all* about you. It is also about all of us. I have no idea how much it is one or the other. Is it 51% about you and 49% about us? Or 10% about us and 90% about you? Or vice-versa? Or maybe thinking of “us” versus “you” is the whole problem. Maybe we’re on the same team. Maybe the distinction between “us” and “you” is a false one and always has been. Anyway, I don’t know where that balance lies, exactly, and I don’t care. But I do know that, one way or another, it needs to be more about us and less about you. As I have already said, “us” is just a big dumb thing that depends on each of us individuals to exist. That is why everything here is written for you. You are the one with the power. It is just a little bit of power, but it is all yours, you don’t have to share it with anyone, and you can do with it what you want. I hope at least one of the things you want to do with your power is to help us be not just OK, but great. The best way you can help us to be great is to be more cooperative, by being more humble, more accepting of the wants, needs, and, especially, points of view of everyone else in this world. To admit that just because something matters to you does not mean it is the only thing that matters. To find some perspective about your own life, and the lives of those around you and to accept our existence when you consider how to act in the world. In the end, it may not always change what you do. Just opening yourself to the possibility is enough. In fact, just being aware of it is enough. This new awareness is not just altruism on your part. The changes underway in the After Age have put pressure on all of us. The pressures are personal, but they also extend into how we treat other people, other groups of people, other nations, how we think about money, and politics, and the world as a whole. I hope by understanding the how and why of some of these pressures you are better equipped to live your best life alongside the rest of us. That said, as I’ve made clear, there is a cost involved in making everything less about you. There is more effort involved. It complicates your own goals, undermines your own certainty. You take on some of the burden of ensuring the health and stability of the society and world around you, often with no obvious immediate personal benefit. To convince you this burden is worth it, I’ve shown you how far we have gotten already and, by implication, how much further we could go. We have entered an era of unprecedented potential that is just getting started. There is no limit to what we could achieve. You want more money? We have been making more money continuously for over 200 years with no sign of stopping. You want more freedom? By every metric, we have been getting freer and freer. You want law and order, peace and security? Human life is less and less violent and more and more just and orderly. You want more happiness? Well..uh..no, sorry, the After Age can’t promise you that and neither will I. However, the After Age can certainly make happiness more likely by creating the circumstances to allow happiness to come into being. The rest is up to you. But I hope by this point you agree with me that the greatest benefit of the After Age is not what it can deliver for you, but what it can deliver for everyone, especially those of us who are much less fortunate than you or I. For that reason alone, we should all be doing what we can to keep the progress of the After Age going. For us and for you, this is a win-win situation. Thank you for reading the After Age. If you’ve gotten this far, then you must have found the ideas in this book worth considering, at least. I have covered a lot of ground here. I would be surprised if you agree with everything I have written. However, if there is one thing I hope this book has encouraged you to do, it is to take a second look at how you think about the world, its present, future, and your place in it. They are all much brighter than you think. *Welcome to the After Age. *